Skip to main content
article icon

Half of 2012 free schools have not secured a site

news | Published in TES magazine on 13 April, 2012 | By: Richard Vaughan

Gove’s flagship policy is in ‘disarray’, the opposition claims

Michael Gove’s flagship free-schools policy was said to be in “disarray” by its critics this week, as it was revealed that just half of the schools due to open this September have secured a site.

The education secretary announced in October that 79 of the state-funded independent schools had been approved to open at the beginning of the next academic year, but doubts are now being expressed over how many will be ready in time.

Responding to a parliamentary question put forward by shadow education secretary Stephen Twigg at the request of TES, schools minister Nick Gibb admitted that only “around half” of the free schools had found a suitable site.

Finding premises is proving particularly difficult in London and the South East, where buildings and land are expensive and hard to come by.

According to the New Schools Network (NSN), a charity that works with free-school applicants, the problem has forced “a number” of free-school groups to postpone opening until next year.

Natalie Evans, NSN’s chief operating officer, described trying to find a suitable site as the “single most challenging aspect” of opening a free school.

“This is something the government really needs to think about,” Ms Evans said. “Finding premises is extremely difficult, and is one of the biggest frustrations and a real headache for groups.”

Last year, just 24 free schools opened, but the number of applications has grown steadily into the hundreds and Ms Evans has questioned whether the newly created Education Funding Agency (EFA) can cope with the demand.

“Finding fit-for-purpose premises for a couple of dozen free schools is one thing, but it is not clear whether the new EFA can manage with the number of requests coming through now,” she said.

One free-school group that has been forced to postpone opening until next year is the Compass Schools Trust, which was given the green light last year to set up a secondary in Southwark, London.

A spokesperson for the trust said that the pressure on space, particularly in major cities, was “frustrating” new school groups.

“Finding a site has been our main issue and has meant that 100 local children, currently in Year 6, will miss out on a start to secondary education that they deserve and that their parents want for them,” the spokesperson said.

It is unclear exactly how many of the schools will open in September, but one that has managed to find suitable premises in time for the next academic year is the Greenwich Free School in southeast London.

Louise Buckley, a governor at the school, said that finding a site was the biggest challenge in setting up the secondary and called on the government to relax some of the rules that prevent groups from speaking to the owners of buildings and land earlier in the process.

“You are told to go out and look for suitable sites before you apply, but not everyone would know whether a building would be suitable for hundreds of kids,” Ms Buckley said. “And you aren’t allowed to enter into a conversation with the owner of a site until after you have been approved.

“It means that you may have found a site but it might not be suitable, and you have to start from scratch again,” she added.

The government was circumspect about the problem. A spokesperson for the Department for Education said: “Over half of the free schools due to open in September 2012 have now confirmed a site, and we are in the middle of negotiations on preferred sites for the large majority of the other projects.”

The difficulty of securing sites for free schools has led to Labour claiming that Mr Gove’s pet policy is in “disarray”.

“The government’s approach to school buildings is chaotic,” Mr Twigg said. “First, the government cut the education building budget by nearly two- thirds - twice the average of other departments. Second, they have delayed their own so-called priority building programme three times. And now their free schools policy is floundering.

“I urge the government to think again and address the real need in the system, where there is an urgent shortage of primary school places,” he added.


More than £330 million has been spent on the government’s free schools and academies programmes since the coalition came to power, figures released by the NUT show.

The teaching union said that it had tracked £337.2 million in payments supporting the free schools and academies programmes since May 2010.

The union also revealed that 126 full-time equivalent staff at the Department for Education are working on the free schools programme, despite just 24 being open and only another 79 being approved to open this year.

“Free schools are absorbing an increasing proportion of DfE staff resources at a time when the Department as a whole is shrinking,” said NUT general secretary Christine Blower. “It is hard to see how the education secretary can justify spending taxpayers’ money in this way.

“This programme will create a chaotic and unaccountable education system.”


Original headline: No home to go to: half of 2012 free schools have not secured a site

Subscribe to the magazine

5 average rating

Comment (2)

  • Everything - and more - of the above is true. The DfE is a vast uncaring unwieldy bureaucracy which obstructs ordinary folk at every single step of the way. Its main tactic is unnecessary delay which causes any local enthusiasm to evaporate.

    It demands that the school is run along DfE lines so that it is far too big, far to controlled and the intake (all important) is selected by the government either LA or else DfE. For secondary schools you have to produce a Comprehensive School which copies the present Comprehensive/Academy pattern.

    Unless you come from a minority - Jewish, Muslim, Montessori etc. Angllican and Catholic Education Authorities simply do not answer letters or even e mails.

    Getting premises is made very difficult - more delay of course - and getting people to construct anything (as you say) apparently comes under EU regs. So you have to advertise Europe wide. More delay.

    The local Grammar (for politicians and rich people) costs £10,000 per year. The local Comprehensive has had five Heads in six years and is hoping its new Academy Status will raise the pass marks at GCSE from 23% and reduce the daily truancy rate from 11%.

    I used to be a fan of Michael Gove. I still am. He used to be right before he was elected.

    But I am not a fan of the DfE at all.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

    Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
    17 April, 2012

    Mike Stallard

  • So what's the solution? This is a genuine question....I find it all so confusing. I thought that free schools sounded like such a great idea...

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

    18 April, 2012


Add your comment

Subscribe to TES magazine
Join TES for free now

Join TES for free now

Four great reasons to join today...

1. Be part of the largest network of teachers in the world – over 2m members
2. Download over 600,000 free teaching resources
3. Get a personalized email of the most relevant resources for you delivered to your inbox.
4. Find out first about the latest jobs in education