Catholic schools fight to demand proof of religion

Government challenged after banning practice of asking for a priest’s certificate
23rd December 2016, 12:00am
Magazine Article Image

Share

Catholic schools fight to demand proof of religion

https://www.tes.com/magazine/archived/catholic-schools-fight-demand-proof-religion

A body representing Catholic schools is going to court to defend a controversial new admissions procedure that allows oversubscribed schools to demand a priest’s certification of religious practice from pupils.

The Catholic Education Service (CES) will be taking its admissions process to judicial review in the new year, after the Office of the Schools Adjudicator (OSA) claimed it was “not an objective measure” of religious practice.

In a series of judgments, the OSA said that the procedure often involved meeting a parish priest to discuss the certification process. It judged that these meetings would breach the schools admissions code because they would constitute “unlawful” interviews.

‘Slightly different standards’

The OSA added that the process left parents subject to the whims of individual priests: “It seems to me entirely plausible, indeed almost inevitable, that different parish priests will apply slightly different standards when deciding if a family should be issued with a Certification of Catholic Practice…potentially affecting admissions to the same school.”

But a spokesman for the CES said that the certification system was fairer than one requiring prospective pupils to demonstrate regular church attendance. He said: “What all parties are looking for is clarity for schools in their admissions policies.

“The central issue here is how to determine whether a pupil is from a practising Catholic family. Within the Catholic community, it is accepted that parish priests are best placed to confirm this.”

The certification allows parish priests to determine on a pupil-by-pupil basis whether children come from practising Catholic families. It replaces the requirement to show commitment to the religion by attending mass regularly. The CES has said that some parents - for example, those who work on the weekend - might not be able to attend mass regularly, despite their commitment to the religion.

It argued that the certification process ensures that measures used to determine Catholic practice are the same across diocesan boundaries.

A headteacher at an oversubscribed Catholic secondary, speaking anonymously to TES, said: “The OSA is stepping on the church’s prerogative.

“It’s entirely for the church to decide who is and is not a practising Catholic, without a secular quangocratic entity stepping in and telling them what priests can and can’t do.”

‘Nonsense’ accusations

However, last month, the OSA upheld a string of complaints, covering five schools, about a perceived lack of clarity over the grounds on which a parish priest would award a certificate of practice. Priority for places at oversubscribed Catholic schools is given to pupils whose parents can provide proof of religious practice.

One complainant - a parent appealing against St Richard Reynolds Catholic College, in Richmond upon Thames - claimed that parents could not easily understand what was required in order to obtain a priest’s backing for their application. The OSA ruled that the certificate was “in the gift of an applicant’s parish priest” and was therefore not objective.

The headteacher of the oversubscribed school said: “The accusation that the church is trying to obfuscate is just nonsense.

“There’s a broader sociocultural war going on here, and this seems to be the front line of it. It’s disappointing that the schools adjudicator seems to be open to the charge of not being impartial.”

@adibloom_tes

You need a Tes subscription to read this article

Subscribe now to read this article and get other subscriber-only content:

  • Unlimited access to all Tes magazine content
  • Exclusive subscriber-only stories
  • Award-winning email newsletters

Already a subscriber? Log in

You need a subscription to read this article

Subscribe now to read this article and get other subscriber-only content, including:

  • Unlimited access to all Tes magazine content
  • Exclusive subscriber-only stories
  • Award-winning email newsletters
Recent
Most read
Most shared