A school leaders’ union has passed a motion of no confidence in Ofsted’s leadership and in its ability to address what it describes as “the damage being done by the new inspection system”.
The Association of School and College Leaders has also agreed that the union will survey members on whether to hold an indicative ballot on industrial action if changes are not made.
ASCL’s council has warned that there has been “no meaningful progress on the part of Ofsted to address significant wellbeing issues caused by inspections”, and that it is “increasingly concerned about the welfare and morale of members”.
In line with fellow school leaders’ union, the NAHT, ASCL has called on the government to pause inspections and review the inspection system as a matter of urgency.
The action comes on the day that Ofsted published an independent evaluation of its report card system.
‘Genuine change’ not currently achievable
Tes first revealed that ASCL was discussing “assertive action” against Ofsted earlier this week.
Today, IFF Research, which was commissioned by Ofsted to evaluate the inspection framework, found that nearly nine in 10 school leaders said inspection had a negative impact on their own or their staff’s mental wellbeing.
The ASCL council’s motion also raises concerns that schools in disadvantaged areas are being “penalised” by the methodology being used in inspections.
Education secretary Lucy Powell reportedly wants the watchdog to review its approach to inspecting inclusion and do more to take schools’ context into account, as Ofsted faces continued pressure to reform.
The ASCL motion adds that “we fear that the disproportionate stress and anxiety exerted by the inspection system will lead to school leaders deciding to leave their posts with a consequent impact on schools, children, and young people”.
ASCL’s council further warns that it “does not believe that genuine change is achievable within the current culture of the inspectorate”.
Ofsted system an ‘overbearing mess’
ASCL general secretary Pepe Di’Iasio said that the action was “not a step we have taken lightly but only after our repeated attempts to resolve our concerns through discussion and negotiation have hit a brick wall”.
He added: “Ofsted’s warm words about recognising wellbeing pressures on school and college leaders have not been matched by the action necessary to dial down the incredibly high stakes of an inspection system which is damaging people’s health and driving them out of the profession.”
The current system is “not fit for purpose”, Mr Di’Iasio said. “It is an overbearing mess and urgently needs to be reviewed”.
Writing for Tes, Ofsted’s national director for education, Lee Owston, acknowledges that IFF Research’s findings are “not all positive”, but says that the inspectorate is “buoyed by the balance in the findings”.