Age of criminal responsibility raised to 12 in Scotland

Children under 12 who commit an offence will no longer be treated as a criminal, but some say age should have been raised to 14 or 16

Tes Reporter

Age of criminal responsibility raised to 12 in Scotland

A new law has come into force meaning no children under 12 will be treated as offenders in the Scottish justice system.

The Age of Criminal Responsibility (Scotland) Act 2019 was passed unanimously in May, with children's minister Maree Todd describing the passage of the bill as a "historic day".

Despite the unanimous approval in Parliament for the new law, Liberal Democrat Alex Cole-Hamilton called for the age to be lifted even higher, to 14 or 16.

Background: Move to raise criminal age to 14 or 16 is rejected

First person: ‘I was a high-achieving pupil – and a gang member’

Long read: Toxic masculinity and boys’ mental health

Social media: What do 12-year-olds think about school?

He claimed the "international community will judge this government as a failure on human rights" for not pushing the age further.

The UN Committee on the Rights of the Child has demanded the age of criminal responsibility in Scotland be raised to 14 "immediately", while the children's commissioner for Scotland, Bruce Adamson, has also made his view clear that 14 is the "lowest acceptable age".

But Ms Todd said: "I promised during the bill process to make this change as early as possible to deliver real change in children's lives.

"These new provisions mean that the behaviour of children under 12 in Scotland will no longer result in them being treated as offenders in the children's hearings system."

She added: "Evidence shows that responding to childhood behaviour in a criminalising, stigmatising way serves only to promote escalation and further harm.

"That is neither in the interests of the child, nor of the safety of our communities."

Ms Todd said: "This marks the first chapter of a groundbreaking reform.

"The act will deliver a progressive, child-centred approach that will make a real difference to children's lives, while victims will continue to get the support they need."

Action for Children director for Scotland Paul Carberry, who was a member of the advisory group in 2015, said: "As long-term advocates of raising of the age of criminal responsibility in Scotland, we welcome the introduction of these provisions which will ensure that children are treated like children in our justice system.

"We fully support the notion that no 8- to 11-year-old should ever be regarded as an 'offender', nor should they be stigmatised in later life as a result of actions as a child, and now this will be enshrined into law.

"The introduction of these provisions is a major step forward and something that is far more consistent with Scotland's approach of prevention and early intervention."

From today, primary-school-age children will no longer be reported to a children's hearing for an offence.

The Scottish government said children under the age of 12 who commit an offence will have their needs addressed without being treated as a criminal.

Register to continue reading for free

It only takes a moment and you'll get access to more news, plus courses, jobs and teaching resources tailored to you

Latest stories