Skip to main content

In brief

Lessons of the Masters: the Charles Eliot Norton lectures. By George Steiner. Harvard University Press pound;12.95.

A child, particularly a young one, will commonly speak not of "our teacher" but, proudly, of "my teacher". That hint of a special, possessive relationship is at the heart of these lectures given by George Steiner at Harvard University last year analysing the age-old relationship between the charismatic "master" - examples include Jesus, Socrates, Virgil, Kepler and Heidegger - and the individual pupil.

It's a densely argued book, but in its affirmation of pedagogy it's timely, given current emphasis on how children learn and the growth of "e-learning". In Steiner's words, "To teach seriously is to lay hands on what is most vital in a human being; to seek access to the quick and the innermost of a child's or an adult's integrity."

He goes on: "Bad teaching is, almost literally, murderous and, metaphorically, a sin." True - but readers might take issue with his assessment that such "anti-teaching is statistically close to being the norm." Is there nothing acceptable between charismatic mastery and its murderous opposite?

Log in or register for FREE to continue reading.

It only takes a moment and you'll get access to more news, plus courses, jobs and teaching resources tailored to you