Dunblane parents sought No 10 answers over U-turn fears

Letter written after the 1996 Dunblane massacre reveals concerns that the government might renege on a pledge to help
31st December 2019, 12:04am

Share

Dunblane parents sought No 10 answers over U-turn fears

https://www.tes.com/magazine/archive/dunblane-parents-sought-no-10-answers-over-u-turn-fears
Dunblane Massacre: Parents Sought Answers From No 10 Over U-turn Fears (picture: Stefan Rousseau/pa Wire)

Grieving parents at Dunblane Primary School demanded an urgent clarification from John Major days after the 1996 massacre amid concern that the government was about to renege on a pledge to help, a newly released letter reveals.

Gerry McDermott, spokesman for the school board of governors, sought answers from Downing Street after reports reached the school that Scottish minister Michael Forsyth had backed down on a commitment to use state funds rather than public donations to rebuild the gym where gunman Thomas Hamilton fired at a class of five- and six-year-olds.

The prime minister and Mr Forsyth were among a delegation of state officials to visit Dunblane after the 13 March attack, and Mr Major confirmed to the headteacher that finding government cash for the project “would not be a problem”.


Dunblane 20 years on: Legacy can be found in child welfare

Revelations from official papers:  Ministers’ concerns over Dunblane ‘cover-up’ fears


Mr McDermott said the gesture “was a source of great comfort” to the community, “relieving strain from those most closely involved”.

However, he accused the government of “manipulating” the community for political gain when he became aware of claims that ministers would abandon the idea in favour of using public donations instead.

In a letter to Mr Major on 27 March, released by the National Archives at Kew, Mr McDermott wrote: “Such an apparent change of heart and broken promise is a cause of great distress in Dunblane.

“I, on behalf of the school board, look to you to clarify in writing exactly what the government will do.

“If there is no intention to fund the rebuilding of the gym, as you promised, this requires to be clearly stated so that the community knows where it stands.”

He said that if claims of Mr Forsyth’s U-turn were true, he wished “to put on record my extreme disappointment in the manner in which this bereaved community has been manipulated, maximising media opportunity, yet failing to deliver a widely reported promise of assistance”.

Mr Forsyth, in a letter responding the same day, told the governors there was no truth in the suggestion, adding: “I simply cannot understand where the report came from…we stand by [the] commitment.”

The Scottish minister - now Lord Forsyth - also conveyed his regret that the board decided to ask Mr Major for assurance directly before approaching him.

“A phone call to my office would have clarified the misapprehension,” he wrote.

The government later met the £2 million cost to refurbish the gym, which was pulled down in the days after the disaster.

Hamilton, 43, shot dead 16 children and their teacher, Gwen Mayor, shortly after 9.30am as they prepared to begin their class.

The killer, described by some neighbours as an oddball who was expelled from the Scouts movement, after exposing boys to extreme cold during two camping expeditions, turned the gun on himself moments later.

A tranche of newly released official correspondence following the Dunblane tragedy also revealed a handwritten note from Mr Forsyth to the prime minister, thanking Mr Major’s wife Norma for being “marvellous” during a visit to the grieving community.

“It cannot have been easy for her,” Mr Forsyth wrote.

Want to keep reading for free?

Register with Tes and you can read two free articles every month plus you'll have access to our range of award-winning newsletters.

Keep reading for just £1 per month

You've reached your limit of free articles this month. Subscribe for £1 per month for three months and get:

  • Unlimited access to all Tes magazine content
  • Exclusive subscriber-only stories
  • Award-winning email newsletters
Recent
Most read
Most shared