David Newnham

THE MAP THAT CHANGED THE WORLD. By Simon Winchester. Viking pound;12.99. TES Direct pound;10.99.

It's difficult to imagine what our forebears made of the world around them - or, in the case of geology, the world underneath them. In 1658, James Ussher, Bishop of Armagh, announced that God began the act of creation at 9am on Monday, October 23, 4004BC, wrapping the job up in time for tea on the following Saturday. For the next 100 years, few questioned His Grace's calculations.

The idea that the process was infinitely more gradual had not been envisaged, and the now familiar mechanisms involved - the heaving up and grinding down of mountains and the painfully slow evolution of species - had yet to be described by the time the industrial revolution got under way. Fortunately, that revolution, with its appetite for coal and iron, was to take men with keen eyes and questioning minds deep into the ground. And such a man was William Smith, the subject of Simon Winchester's book.

A man of humble origins, Smith was working as a surveyor in a Somerset coal mine when he became fascinated by the sequence of rock strata visible in the rough-hewn walls. What if that vertical sequence of layers were repeated elsewhere - in Somerset, in England, or elsewhere in the world? It was his next job - as surveyor to a canal company - that gave Smith the opportunity to test his theory. Slicing through the Somerset countryside, he realised that the various strata could be identified precisely by the fossils they contained. And the sequence was indeed consistent.

It was in 1815, after a decade and a half of single-handed labour, that Smith finally published his masterpiece - a 50-foot-square, hand-coloured map of the geology of England and Wales. Here, for the first time, was visible evidence of the Earth's slow history, and that, says Winchester, was enough to change our view of the world. But did the world thank Smith, and rush to name him the father of English geology?

If you've read Dava Sobel's Longitude, the book that opened the new market for narrative non-fiction that Winchester's book is aiming for, you'll know that advancing the sum of human knowledge is easy - it's gaining recognition that takes a lifetime.

For many readers - and, no doubt, television producers, for it's difficult to avoid seeing this as a made-for-television drama - it's the familiar human story of triumph over obscurity that will appeal. But, unfortunately, it is in this area - one that demands the best writing - that Winchester's over-egged prose lets him down. With a little more directness and a lot less melodrama, this would have been a far better book.

When explaining the geology, he performs admirably (a glossary is included), and few will reach the final chapter without catching something of the author's wonder at the majesty of the world beneath our feet.


Register to continue reading for free

It only takes a moment and you'll get access to more news, plus courses, jobs and teaching resources tailored to you

David Newnham

Latest stories