# 'The government is micromanaging with the new times tables test – for goodness' sake, leave teachers to get on with their job'

Of course pupils should know their times tables, but the level of interference from the government is inappropriate, obsessive and, frankly, laughable, says experienced leader Bernard Trafford

When I find myself feeling sorry for a government minister, I fear I’m starting to go soft.

But on Wednesday I pitied schools minister Nick Gibb on Good Morning Britain, in an interview that subsequently hurtled around the Twittersphere. Talking about his new quick five-minute tables test for primary school children, he was put on the spot about his own knowledge of the topic. Resolutely he refused to answer, observing that he knew that trap all too well: he wasn’t going to be sidetracked from the main issue. Damned if he did, and damned if he didn’t – the interviewers had turned the tables on him.

I was interviewed on local radio station that same morning and was miffed not to be asked to recite my eight-times table, which I’m good at. At primary school in the early 1960s, we would happily chant around the class: “Once two is two, two twos are four,” right up to, “Twelve twelves are 144.”

My best maths teacher, a former colonel of artillery in World War Two, taught the 10-year-old me how use a slide-rule (remember those?), to round up or down and apply times tables to gain a rough estimate of the correct answer, if only to ensure the decimal point was in the right place.

I remember every one of those tables and still employ those solidly-learned estimation techniques while obsessively calculating how long the next 8 miles will take me when I’m traveling on the motorway at 70 mph.

## Times tables furore

While I still find it easy to translate those chanted tables into mathematical applications, the same is not true of every learner. Merely teaching the tables by rote will not solve this country’s mathematical woes. Teachers must still assess their pupils’ understanding and intervene when the scaffolding of learning, of which tables are indeed a useful part, isn’t coming together as it should.

Policymakers wouldn’t deny that fact: nonetheless, this tables test has caused a furore. Supporters wonder why someone such as the NAHT headteachers’ union's Nick Brook has come out against it. What harm is there in a simple five-minute test? Surely it’s good to know how one’s pupils are doing?

The trouble is, however, that we Brits invariably fetishise tests. Brook reckons Ofsted will be keeping an eye on the results. Oops! Too easily it moves from a simple matter of seeing whether the kids know their tables to assessing the performance of the school: or checking whether the school is doing tables in the “approved way”. I don’t spend my life looking for conspiracies, but I’m afraid I don’t trust the government not to use this mechanism to enforce the orthodoxy they demand.

## Government micromanagement

We’ve already had government insisting that the only way to teach reading is through phonics, rather than using them as one (admittedly valuable) approach of several available. This latest test smacks (not for the first time) of Emperor Napoleon’s centralised approach to education: in 1802 it was said that he knew what every schoolchild in France was learning at any particular time.

Do sanctuary buildings mandarins seek similar control of our school system? I frequently fear they do. This tables test, small enough in itself, is symbolic of government micromanagement: the level of interference is inappropriate, obsessive and, frankly, laughable.

It’s the role of government to set standards – and to support (rather than to bully) schools in working to achieve them. It should treat maths teachers as professionals, supporting and funding the best of training and continuing professional development so that they may constantly hone and develop their skills.

But first, for goodness sake, it should stop telling them how to do their job.

Dr Bernard Trafford is a writer, educationalist and musician. He is a former headteacher of the Royal Grammar School, Newcastle, and past chair of HMC. He is currently interim headteacher of the Purcell School in Hertfordshire. He tweets @bernardtrafford

To read more of his columns, view his back catalogue

Want to keep up with the latest education news and opinion? Follow Tes on Twitter and like Tes on Facebook

It only takes a moment and you'll get access to more news, plus courses, jobs and teaching resources tailored to you

## Latest stories

### Reforms to language GCSEs 'risk standards,' say MPs

DfE plans to base GCSEs solely on the 2,000 most frequent words will overlook communication skills and culture, say experts
Dave Speck 13 May 2021

### Today's school, education and teacher news: LIVE 12/5

The hub for specialist education news for those working in schools and everyone who is interested in them
Tes Reporter 12 May 2021

### Covid inquiry must probe DfE response, say teachers

Union warns that 'lessons must be learned' from the government's record on education during the pandemic
Catherine Lough 12 May 2021

### Careers education toolkit launched to boost 'parity'

Exclusive: High-quality, high impact careers education should be inclusive for all learners, says the Careers and Enterprise Company's Oli de Botton
Kate Parker 12 May 2021

### Do we challenge our own perspectives on race enough?

This leader has always been keen to promote diversity at her college, but the last year has left her wondering if there is more she could have done
Sally Dicketts 12 May 2021

### Teaching students first aid is more important than ever

First aid is now a compulsory part of the curriculum, but this isn't the only reason schools should focus on the subject. Two teachers explain how it can bring out the best in students
Chloe Albasini 12 May 2021

### Ofsted: Six ways to improve RE teaching

Inspectorate sets out what it believes are the key factors to a successful religious education curriculum
John Roberts 12 May 2021

### Covid-proof next year's 11-plus tests, grammars advised

Grammars must use catch-up funding to support applicants from poorer households, says DfE
Dave Speck 12 May 2021

### New Covid rules: 8 questions that still need answers

Many of the government's restrictions are set to lift on May 17, but schools still have questions about what this means for them
Grainne Hallahan 12 May 2021

### Teachers 'being set up to take the fall' over exams

Opposition MSPs also hit out at 'farcical suggestion' that pupils will be punished for sharing exam details
Emma Seith & Henry Hepburn 12 May 2021