Minister wants academy trusts to keep their 'failings' secret

Lord Agnew urges extra checks on academy chains to avoid problems being made public

Martin George

Lord Agnew told auditors they could stop failings of academies entering the public record by having mid-year audit reviews.

Academy trusts should have mid-year audit review to prevent the public finding out about their failings, the academies minister has said.

Lord Agnew outlined his advice in a letter he sent to auditors today about academy trust financial management and governance.

The letter, published by the DfE, says the department is “particularly concerned” when it sees that issues raised by an auditor in one year “remain unresolved in the following year”.

Quick read: Agnew's secrecy over AET's £16m turnaround plan

Failure: Wakefield City Academies Trust gives up all its schools

Governance: DfE plan to blacklist academy trustee 'chancers'

Lord Agnew writes: “Our view is that a simple way to avoid these failings going onto the public record is through mid-year audit reviews. This gives management teams the time to resolve them before the accounts have to be signed.”

The letter was published on the day Lord Agnew refused to give MPs details of how one of England's biggest academy trusts is using public money.

There have been long-running concerns about secrecy in the academy sector.

In January, a report from the Commons Public Accounts Committee, said academy trusts do not make enough information available for parents and local communities.

There have also been complaints about a lack of transparency about the regional schools commissioner system which oversees the academy system, which the DfE has since taken some steps to address.

In his letter, Lord Agnew anticipates that some academy trusts may raise concerns about the extra cost of carrying out mid-year audit reviews.

However, he writes: “Siren voices that complain about the cost of this action should be cause for concern in itself. Normally the failings identified will have a cost well in excess of an audit review.

“The sooner they are rectified the less risk and cost to the trust." 

The minister also acknowledges that “many academy trust boards are still adjusting to the additional rigour expected of them, when compared to being a local authority school governing body”, and emphasises the role of auditors in helping such boards.

Lord Agnew’s missive follows a number of high-profile failures in the academy sector.

In today’s letter, Lord Agnew urges auditors to speak the DfE directly about “serious concerns” they may have about an academy trust, even if this is not the usual procedure they would follow.

He writes: “If you identify serious concerns about an academy trust, we would always encourage you to speak to us early in the process.

“Whilst this is a matter for your professional judgment, there may be rare occasions where delay, and reliance on the standard channels for reporting audit findings, runs the risk of significant irregularity or impropriety.”



Register to continue reading for free

It only takes a moment and you'll get access to more news, plus courses, jobs and teaching resources tailored to you

Martin George

Martin George

Martin George is a reporter at Tes

Find me on Twitter @geomr

Latest stories

Technology to support hybrid teaching and learning

Impactful technologies to support the blended classroom

Choosing which tech teachers should use to manage a blended classroom can feel like a minefield. Here, one edtech expert sets out the technologies that can truly enhance hybrid teaching and learning
Tristan Kirkpatrick 27 Jul 2021