Pisa divides opinions

John Bangs

I agree with Andreas Schleicher's rejection of academic criticisms that the Programme for International Student Assessment is fundamentally flawed ("Attacks on Pisa are entirely unjustified", Comment, 2 August). No assessment is perfect but Pisa's methodology is thoroughly interrogated and about as rigorous as it can be. It is also worth remembering that, with its focus on the use and application of knowledge and equity of achievement, Pisa provides powerful evidence for those of us who believe in inclusive and comprehensive education systems.

What is frustrating about these criticisms is that they are a diversion from key questions about Pisa outcomes. Are the results from the three "literacies" a sufficient proxy for a 360-degree evaluation of a country's education system? Given that the body behind Pisa, the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), has acknowledged that uncertainty is part of the Pisa outcomes, should this not form a high-profile caveat in the reports? Shouldn't the OECD be more robust in rejecting outrageous ministerial claims for Pisa evidence?

The worst mistake would be to shoot the Pisa messenger instead of using its evidence to create powerful arguments against those who propose the dismantling of public education.

John Bangs, Chair of the OECD Trade Union Advisory Committee's working group on education.

Register to continue reading for free

It only takes a moment and you'll get access to more news, plus courses, jobs and teaching resources tailored to you

John Bangs

Latest stories

Student support: three ways to help Year 13s navigate this year

Three ways colleges can support Year 13s this year

The future may be uncertain for all of us – but for Year 13s who will progress from FE next summer, it's more precarious than most. Alfie Payne sets out how to best support those students
Alfie Payne 26 Sep 2020

Coronavirus and schools: LIVE 25/9

A one-stop shop for teachers who want to know what impact the ongoing pandemic will have on their working lives
Tes Reporter 25 Sep 2020