In Scotland, the situation is more rigorous. The Scottish Office wrote to all local authorities four years ago asking that if they dismissed a teacher for gross professional misconduct they should report this to the General Teaching Council. A criminal prosecution or police involvement is not a prerequisite. This reporting is not statutory, but Scottish local authorities comply with it.
Cases referred to the GTC are considered using the standard proof of beyond reasonable doubt. The GTC has the power to strike teachers off its register, preventing them from working for an LEA. Its power does not extend to independent schools, but many would report matters of misconduct to it.
Allegations against teachers need to be investigated thoroughly, as false allegations are made, but if the new English and Welsh GTCs were given the same powers as the Scottish GTC, there would be no need for secret lists.
Professional Association of Teachers