Revealed: Durand Academy's £100K caretaker

Caretaker who is also a trustee at the embattled academy was paid three times the going rate, including £39,000 lump sum covering eight years of unclaimed annual leave

Charlotte Santry

News article image

A caretaker at a controversial academy trust was paid at least £100,000 last year – including a one-off payment of £39,000 for eight years of unclaimed holiday, Tes can reveal.

The one-off payment to Brendan McShane is understood to have been signed off by the school's former headteacher Mark McLaughlin.

Mr McLaughlin left in August 2017, after the Department for Education decided to withdraw funding from the trust following concerns about its financial management and governance.

Durand's website describes Mr McShane as its premises manager, though he was also named by the trust as its caretaker when contacted by Tes.

A source in the academy trust's governing body said: "The governors were completely unaware that this payment had been made. The first we heard of it was when the auditors alerted us."

Mr McShane was paid between £100,000 and £105,000 in 2016-17, according to the trust's latest financial accounts – an increase from the £75,000 to £80,000 he received the previous year. 

Tes data shows that premises managers attract an average salary of between £27,500 to £31,500 in London, and £21,550 to £24,00 outside of London.

Phillip Reynolds, senior manager at accountancy firm Kreston Reeves who works with the academies sector, said: "Anything above £40,000 is odd, unless it's for a large multi-academy trust." 

Asked how common it was for academies to pay a lump sum in lieu of years of accrued annual leave, he said: "I've definitely not seen that before."

In the commercial sector, it was not unheard of for a payment to be given to an employee who had agreed not to take annual leave while working hard on a particular project, he said. "But even then, eight years seems outside the norm."

He added: "And this isn't commercial, this is a school. It's public money."

Mr McShane is a trustee of Durand Academy Trust (DAT) as well as being a director of Durand Education Trust (DET) – the company that owns the land on which the school sits and at which Mr McLaughlin is also a director. 

The Education and Skills Funding Agency has previously demanded that no DAT director was also a director of DET.

DET contracts London Horizons, the firm owned by the school's outspoken founder Sir Greg Martin, to run a leisure facility on the school site.

Sir Greg famously received a salary of nearly £400,000 in 2012-13, made up of income from the leisure centre as well as his pay as Durand's former headteacher. He resigned as headteacher in 2015, and stood down as the school's chair of governors last August.

A Durand Academy Trust spokesman said: "The payment was made for the holidays which Mr McShane was entitled to as per his employment contract with the academy, and the holidays had been accrued over the last eight years because of ongoing major building works at different sites.

"It is understood that there had been arrangements between the staff member and the senior management of the academy that any accrued holidays would be utilised at a future period.

"This arrangement was appeared to have been historically approved by the board. In April 2017, the staff member was offered payment in lieu of the accrued holidays."

Regarding Mr McShane's directorship of DET, the spokesperson said Durand was "seeking further advice on this matter".

A DfE spokesperson said: “It is essential that taxpayers’ money is used responsibly. We investigate all allegations of financial impropriety. Following previous findings of financial mismanagement, Durand Academy Trust’s funding agreement will be terminated on 29 June 2018. 

“As outlined in the notices sent in July 2016 and October 2016 there have been serious concerns about the financial management and governance of the trust. We continue to have those concerns and have accordingly taken this termination action.”

Register to continue reading for free

It only takes a moment and you'll get access to more news, plus courses, jobs and teaching resources tailored to you

Charlotte Santry

Charlotte Santry

Charlotte Santry is Deputy news editor at Tes

Find me on Twitter @CharlotteSantry

Latest stories

2020 international events calendar for schools

How to plan your CPD calendar for the year

Good quality CPD is absolutely key for staff retention, but throwing together ad-hoc sessions doesn’t help anyone. One school leader explains how to plan ahead
Oliver Saunders 22 Oct 2020