Safety issues threaten exchange programme

UK may miss out on Erasmus scheme for secondary pupils

Michael Shaw

News article image

A plan to let secondary pupils across Europe spend up to a year at school abroad is being opposed by British officials because of stringent UK child protection requirements.

The European Commission (EC) hopes to start the scheme within a year and sees it as the secondary school equivalent to the popular Erasmus universities programme.

The scheme has already been trialled in 10 other EU countries, with 288 14 to 18-year-olds staying with host families in 2007-08.

But UK and Irish officials have said the scheme would be "utterly impractical" for their countries given the child protection checks that would be necessary.

Schools in Britain have already encountered difficulties arranging even short-term exchanges because of the need to carry out criminal record checks on all adults involved.

UK and Irish officials also fear their schools could be inundated with demand for visits.

The British Council is prepared to oversee the project in the UK if it proceeds. But Simon Williams, director of lifelong learning, said that other challenges included arranging visits that would not affect British pupils' exam preparations, and finding enough host families.

"Traditional exchanges involve a lot of paperwork, but hosting a child for a year would be much more onerous and intrusive," he said.

More than 1,000 UK schools have already established close ties with European counterparts through the EC's Comenius school partnership programme.

Jan Figel, the EU commissioner responsible for education, this week said he hoped to launch the Comenius "individual pupil mobility" scheme within 12 months.

"At university level, we have the famous, successful programme - Erasmus," he said. "We would like to get that at secondary level."

Asked about the child protection concerns, he told The TES: "There are some - I would even say many - obstacles. But as we have succeeded in the university community, I'm sure that we can address these."

Representatives from education ministries, including the UK's Department for Children, Schools and Families, will meet next month to thrash out the details of the scheme.

Nine out of 10 teenagers on the pilot project said they had been highly satisfied by the experience.

Wenke, a 15-year-old German, spent six months at a school in France. "Some of my German friends told me they would be scared to go abroad for such a long time. But for me this was a great experience," she said.

Adam Pokorny, head of Comenius's school education unit, said a Finnish colleague had been astonished at how French pupils had conversed in Finnish after only a few months in the country.

A Department for Children, Families and Schools spokesman said: "The safety of our children remains our primary concern, so any scheme that is brought in will need to satisfy the child protection safeguards that are introduced here."

Bonjour, Europe, pages 30-31.

Register to continue reading for free

It only takes a moment and you'll get access to more news, plus courses, jobs and teaching resources tailored to you

Michael Shaw

I'm the director of TES Pro and former deputy editor of the TES magazine. I joined the publication as a news reporter back in 2002, and have worked in a variety of journalistic roles including editing its comment and news pages. In 2013 I set up the app version of the magazine, TES Reader, and the free TES Jobs app Michael Shaw

Latest stories

2020 international events calendar for schools

How to plan your CPD calendar for the year

Good quality CPD is absolutely key for staff retention, but throwing together ad-hoc sessions doesn’t help anyone. One school leader explains how to plan ahead
Oliver Saunders 26 Oct 2020
Class book review: Wink by Rob Harrell

Class book review: Wink

This account of cancer – based on the author's experiences – made our reviewers cry, laugh and keep turning the pages
Gill Ward 25 Oct 2020