‘What we desperately need is a secretary of state rather less anxious to fiddle around with exams’

14th August 2014 at 12:20


Barnaby Lenon, chairman of the Independent Schools Council and former head master of Harrow school, writes:  

So, the first year with no January AS or A2 papers. Schools know that the January resits have hitherto helped to improve their pupils’ results, but there has been general acceptance that the decision to end January exams was a good one – there were just too many exams, too much resitting of modules, too much grade inflation.

Ofqual has ensured that the national pattern of grades looks similar to last year. They are holding back grade inflation while protecting the interests of this year’s candidates. 

The 2014 results show some important trends in terms of subject choice.  The EBacc league table measure generated a significant increase last year in the numbers taking GCSEs in modern languages, geography and history; many of the same students have now taken these subjects through to AS-level. So while the numbers taking Spanish at A-level fell this year, we can be sure they will rise next year. Extended projects are growing in popularity, giving the students who take them an advantage in terms of university entry.

Looking to the future, there is understandable nervousness about the scale of impending changes – but only three GCSEs are being reformed for teaching starting in 2015 and, at A-level, only those subjects that were felt to require very limited change will kick off in that same year. It should be perfectly possible to handle change on this scale.

Exam boards are now submitting their draft A-level specifications and sample assessment materials to Ofqual for approval. Once approved, they will be published immediately and this will allow schools to decide what to offer in a year’s time. Last year 93.7 per cent of independent school pupils sat A-levels, but a slowly growing number take the Pre-U, international A-level or IB as alternatives; what happens next depends in good measure on the details of the reformed A-level syllabuses.

What about Tristram Hunt's statement that he will "put on hold the Tory reforms of A-levels if Labour is elected next May"? This is the kind of political interference with the assessment system that teachers and pupils have suffered from for years. It means that schools will be unsure about preparing for the reformed AS and A-levels. Any such uncertainty might drive some independent schools into the arms of the international A-level and Pre-U, creating once again a split between the independent and maintained sectors.

It implies that "putting on hold" the reforms with three months' notice is a simple matter. The old syllabuses will have been withdrawn by then, new textbooks published and ordered, training courses delivered. 

Mr Hunt speaks as if he knows what is best for schools and universities. But, in fact, schools and universities had mixed responses to the Gove reforms. Some universities wanted to retain the coupled AS, others didn't. University staff have written the reformed AS and A-level specifications and regard them as a better preparation for university than the current courses.

After the shambles of the Ed Balls Diploma, the speed of the Gove reforms and the prospect of a Labour government initiating another round of reform (because it simply won't be a matter of just reverting to the old system), what England desperately needs now is a secretary of state for education who is rather less anxious to make a mark by fiddling around with public examinations designed for the more able and has a bit more enthusiasm for dealing with the main issue in British education – the underachievement of the bottom third of pupils.

Related links:

A-level results: A*s rise but over-all passes drop

TES editorial: 'This morning's A-level results are a big win for teachers, not a green light for meddling




Get TES online and delivered to your door – for less than the price of a coffee

Save 33% off the cover price with this great subscription offer. Every copy delivered to your door by first-class post, plus full access to TES online and the TES app for just £1.90 per week.
Subscribers also enjoy a range of fantastic offers and benefits worth over £270:

  • Discounts off TES Institute courses
  • Access over 200,000 articles in the TES online archive
  • Free Tastecard membership worth £79.99
  • Discounts with Zipcar, Buyagift.com, Virgin Wines and other partners
Order your low-cost subscription today