Skip to main content

Secondary heads call for faster processes to deal with bad teachers

Frustration over ‘interminable’ waits to address small number of failing staff

News article image

Frustration over ‘interminable’ waits to address small number of failing staff

Scotland’s secondary headteachers’ orgainsation has raised concerns that it can take longer than two-and-a-half years for an incompetent teacher to be removed from the classroom.

School Leaders Scotland (SLS) said it is reasonably happy with the procedures that exist in schools, but it queries whether the General Teaching Council for Scotland (GTCS) has the capacity to process cases.

“When it gets to the point where the local authority refers the case to the GTCS, it can take an interminable amount of time to be dealt with,” said SLS general secretary Jim Thewliss.

He added: “You can identify a member of staff whose performance needs to be supported, that can then enter into performance management, and by the time you have gone through the whole system, it can take anything from 18 months to two-and-a-half years, sometimes longer.

"What that means is that you have a member of staff around whom you have concerns over competence, who is in there teaching kids and not improving.”

Thewliss stressed that the number of teachers who should be removed is quite small – and certainly not in the hundreds – and that most teachers who are struggling respond positively to support when provided.

However, he said that in instances in which teachers fail to improve, “we need to make sure that kids’ education is not being damaged for an undue length of time”.

Thewliss added: “There is a process there and we are happy with that process per se. What we would like to introduce is more rigour, so that we get to a conclusion more quickly than we do just now.”

Processes not followed

The SLS call came amid concern about the Scottish government’s proposal to expand the GTCS to become an Education Workforce Council for a wider range of education workers; the GTCS estimates that the number of registrants might rise from 74,500 currently to 203,750 under the new body.

EIS teaching union general secretary Larry Flanagan said that when a case involving concerns about a teacher is referred to the GTCS, it should be dealt with “expeditiously”. But first, he said, all stages in the fitness-to-teach process must be exhausted – including teachers being provided with adequate support. He added that delays can occur when earlier stages have not been implemented, which requires the process to be restarted.

Flanagan said: “We find sometimes it can take a significant length of time before you get to a hearing. But quite often the key thing for us is that the earlier stages of the process have not been addressed adequately.”

A GTCS spokeswoman said: “The GTCS recently revised its fitness-to-teach framework to streamline its regulatory processes. It is entirely possible within this new framework for a professional-competence case to be processed within a matter of months.”

She added: “This is an issue in the first instance for employers to manage. For a number of reasons, the GTCS does not always receive referrals regarding professional competence from employers of teachers, and the issues in this context are both complex and challenging. The GTCS is working with employers to increase awareness and understanding of its processes and recently established a fitness-to-teach employer stakeholder group to facilitate two-way dialogue on issues such as this.”

This is an extract of an article published in 9 February edition of Tes Scotland. Subscribers can read the full story here. To subscribe, click here. To download the digital edition, Android users can click here and iOS users can click here. Tes Scotland magazine is available at all good newsagents.

Log in or register for FREE to continue reading.

It only takes a moment and you'll get access to more news, plus courses, jobs and teaching resources tailored to you