Hard facts to follow
It brings school science closer to real life and often saves you getting too close. Short Circuit, the BBC series for Year 10 and 11, starts a new series in November. Not only is it about real-life science, but as a result of BBC Education listening to teachers, it's promising to be about teachers' real needs too. It's part of a first wave of re-thought TV offerings, which includes a new Science in Action series next term.
The first Short Circuit is about homeostasis, one of the many abstract ideas that teachers have identified as tricky and needing help with. It tells the science behind the story of Leah Betts, the teenager who died after taking Ecstasy.
Her last hours are reconstructed, and her parents and tablet-sharing friend talk about what happened. We hear scientists saying that Ecstasy confuses the hypothalamus in the brain, leaving the body temperature to soar while teenagers dance energetically.
But then we hear that Leah was not dancing and that she did not overheat. She took an overdose of water because her body control system was telling her the wrong things. This is not just a powerful and sad story, it's an excellent way to hold the science together and to see a real hypothalamus, watch sweat forming and see what is in a kidney. The curriculum links are evident and relevant.
In educational television the producers have usually called the shots, choosing the "sexier" topics that made "good TV". Topics like genetics where the potential for practical work is almost zero were either avoided or dealt with in a more dry and up-front way.
Teachers said that programmes were never called what they were - so that, say, Second Birthday was used as a title for something about heart transplants, and helped no one in choosing material for their courses.
But, from now on, a BBC spade will be a curriculum spade as this series of Short Circuit features titles such as Photosynthesis, Radioactivity and Space. Though there's not, I must add cheekily, anything about electricity.
While the Leah Betts story is a hard act to follow, the other programmes still work on a similar human level. In Radioactivity, we see sporting injuries diagnosed using isotopes and scientists searching for atomic bomb-making terrorists, while curriculum imperatives, like half-lives and types of radiation, are also covered. In Genetics, we join dog breeders and learn how they breed faster greyhounds and nastier pit bull terriers. Along the way, we pick up the science of genes, such as dominance and DNA.
The programmes have no on-screen presenter and are all the cleverer for holding together without one. Producer Hugh Mason feels that children of this age are more cynical and aware of the world so he's used this "real-life story" treatment, as opposed to a presented or "in yer face" science. He sees his job here as helping students get an overview of the subject. "The programmes help to make a framework about the subject, such that the teacher can fill in the depth about, say, the working of the hypothalamus. It's much harder to create that overview if you've only a stick of chalk," he says.
Of the BBC's secondary science series, the long-running Science in Action is used by 68 per cent of schools, while the newer Short Circuit, for ages 11 to 14, scores 38 per cent. That's a lot of people deciphering TV listings to record programmes, a lot of TV trolleys battling through corridors and, for all that, lots of people must value this brilliant resource. Over the next few years, this two-series offering will continue as, hopefully, more of what teachers have been saying about what's needed gets translated into programmes.
The first five re-styled Short Circuit science programmes show on BBC2 at 11.20 to 11.40 every Friday from November 1. Teachers notes are available, price Pounds 5 from BBC Educational Publishing, PO Box 234, Wetherby, LS23 7EU. Order line: 01937 541001.
The new series of Science in Action begins on April 17 1997