Labour sends in 'help squads'

23rd May 1997 at 01:00
Ministers made clear this week that tough measures to deal with poor schools are being planned for the autumn.

The Government has singled out 18 of the 300 on the failing list and given them until September to improve or face more drastic pressure while ministers consider the legal powers required to force the closure of schools.

According to Stephen Byers, the new minister for school standards, the White Paper will contain proposals for closing schools and making a fresh start with new senior staff on the same site.

The schools identified on Tuesday are to be offered "help squads" in the form of heads or advisers. The Department for Education and Employment is recruiting professionals who have experience of tackling failing schools and they will be available to schools for between five and 10 days (at a daily fee of #163;400). The professionals are to form what David Blunkett,the Education and Employment Secretary, describes as an #233lite Special Measures Action Recovery Team.

On the Government's list are 11 secondaries, six primaries and one special school. They include Handsworth Wood Boys' in Birmingham, which the local authority is planning to close in July next year, and Lillian Bayliss in the London borough of Lambeth, which has been under special measures for more than three years.

Among the primaries is Morningside in the London borough of Hackney, originally described by inspectors as having such low standards of behaviour that they contributed to making the school neither safe nor secure.

Mr Blunkett insists that the Government's approach is a mixture of support and pressure. Schools are to be encouraged to consider such measures as:

* changing the leadership;

* drafting a clear action plan;

* dealing firmly with incompetent teachers;

* changing the name of the school;

* adding new governors, and;

* adopting a consistent behaviour policy.

Schools identified by the Office for Standards in Education have been allowed to drift for up to 18 months to two years, he said. In an interview with The TES, he said: "This cannot be allowed to happen. They have been like ships tossed around on the ocean in unfavourable winds."

The Government, he suggested, would be willing to take the legal measures required to ensure action could be taken at an early stage and that might involve allowing local authorities to over-rule governors.

However, the decision to produce a list of failing schools has infuriated the teacher unions who accuse ministers of subjecting schools to public humiliation.

Doug McAvoy, the general secretary of the National Union of Teachers, said: "This is a very disappointing approach from the new Labour Education Secretary. It cannot be aimed at helping those schools improve, as he admits he does not know what steps have already been taken."

In the main, the local authorities involved have expressed a willingness to accept the extra assistance, but education directors have complained that some schools on the list are showing significant improvement. David Sands, the acting director in the London borough of Croydon, said the council has spent more than #163;500,000 tackling problems in the two borough schools on the list.

At Ashburton High, a 900-pupil comprehensive, the authority has appointed an acting head and two extra deputies to improve management. At the other school, Ingram High, there are plans to move to a new site, and a new head will be in place in September.

There are now 309 secondaries and primaries - around 2 per cent of schools - that have been identified as failing to provide minimum standards of education. The numbers will rise as the remaining 116 secondaries and 7,600 primaries are inspected for the first time.

Failing schools tend to be concentrated in urban areas, but there are a number of primaries in difficulty in rural Norfolk. The highest count is in inner London, where there are 45; Lambeth alone has 15.

According to Mr Byers, the vast majority of failing schools are improving; some are showing steady improvement, while others are improving at an impressive rate.

The 18 schools named, he said, represent a hard core where significant improvement has not taken place.

Officials from the 18 schools are to be required to present their recovery plans to the DFEE. The schools that fail to improve by the September deadline may have to accept the replacement of senior staff. Schools are unlikely to close without the agreement of their local authorities.Across the country, the November 1996 performance tables showed that 44.5 per cent of pupils gained five or more GCSEs at grades A to C. The national average in 1995 tables was 43.5 per cent.

The average aggregate score for 11-year-olds in this year's primary league table was 170.

The schools to be helped (with league table results in brackets) are:

Earl Marshall, Sheffield, identified as failing in July 1995. (GCSE 1995, 6 per cent; 1996, 8 per cent).

Ashburton High, Croydon, identified as failing in May 1995. (GCSE 1995, 13 per cent; 1996, 18 per cent).

Ingram High, Croydon, identified as failing in May 1995. (GCSE 1995, 19 per cent; 1996, 22 per cent)

Dulwich High, Southwark, identified as failing in March 1995. (GCSE 1995, 11 per cent; 1966, 9 per cent).

Southfields GM, Kent, identified as failing March 1995. (GCSE 1995, 6 per cent; 1996, 9 per cent).

Kelsey Park GM, Bromley, Kent, identified as failing in December 1995. (GCSE 1995, 24 per cent; 1996, 27 per cent).

Our Lady of Fatima GM, Liverpool, identified December 1995. (GCSE 1995, 4 per cent; 1996, 7 per cent).

Upbury Manor GM, Kent, identified as failing in January 1995. (GCSE 1995,6 per cent; 1996, 7 per cent).

Blakelaw, Newcastle, identified in March 1996. (GCSE 1995, 11 per cent; 1996, 10 per cent).

Handsworth Wood Boys, Birmingham, February 1995. (GCSE 1995, 9 per cent; 1996, 11 per cent).

Lillian Bayliss school, Lambeth, identified in January 1994. (GCSE 1995, 8 per cent; 1996, 17 per cent).

Mostyn Gardens primary, Lambeth, identified in June 1995. (Key stage 2 score 107).

South Benwell primary, Newcastle,identified in February 1995. (Key stage 2 score 50).

St Mary of the Angels, Westminster, identified in September 1995. (Key stage 2 score 130).

Abbey Farm middle school, Thetford, Norfolk, identified in November 1995.(Key stage 2 score not available).

Rams Episcopal, Hackney, identified in March 1995. (Key stage 2 score 93).

Morningside primary, Hackney, identified in March 1995 (Key stage 2 score 34).

Lea Green special school, Waltham Forest, identified in February 1996.

Subscribe to get access to the content on this page.

If you are already a TES/ TESS subscriber please log in with your username or email address to get full access to our back issues, CPD library and membership plus page.

Not a subscriber? Find out more about our subscription offers.
Subscribe now
Existing subscriber?
Enter subscription number


Get Tes online and delivered to your door – for less than the price of a coffee

Save 33% off the cover price with this great subscription offer. Every copy delivered to your door by first-class post, plus full access to Tes online and the Tes app for just £1.90 per week.
Subscribers also enjoy a range of fantastic offers and benefits worth over £270:

  • Discounts off Tes Institute courses
  • Access over 200,000 articles in the Tes online archive
  • Free Tastecard membership worth £79.99
  • Discounts with Zipcar,, Virgin Wines and other partners
Order today