Slip of the tongues has left us tied to a monolingual future

15th December 2006 at 00:00
The woefully wrong decision to drop compulsory foreign languages in secondary schools has led to an alarming decline in the number of students studying them at A-level. Sadly, Lord Dearing's interim report, aimed at tackling the crisis (see page 10), is unlikely to halt the slide.

Universities are finding it hard to retain departments in foreign languages and culture. That means Britain is producing fewer teachers specialising in German, French or Russian. Thus the spiral of turning schools into foreign-language-free zones continues.

All this was predicted when Estelle Morris, then Education Secretary, gave way to the monolingualists in Great Smith Street and decided to lift the state schools' obligation to try at least to put some knowledge of European languages into the heads of the next generation.

What is surprising is the speed of the reduction in language teaching in schools. Now, university teachers are in open panic about the declining numbers of applicants to study foreign languages at degree level.

As Europe minister at the time of the decision, I fought in vain to get the Department for Education and Skills to reconsider. But in the finest Whitehall tradition it was made clear that it was no business of a Europe minister to argue that Europe's languages should feature on the school curriculum. Apart from Tony Blair who, as a result of this policy error, may be the last British Prime Minister with a working knowledge of another European tongue (French), the upper reaches of ministerial cohorts are strictly monolingual.

It is alarming that Britain is opting for monolingualism in a globalised world. The first sight that greets a visitor at a United States airport are signs in Spanish as well as English. The US is well on its way to becoming a bilingual country. In the rest of Europe, it would be unthinkable to have ministers, editors or business leaders who were monolingual.

It is not just a question of Britain's economic future. Who, after all, knows England who only English knows? From Shakespeare to James Joyce, the greatest shapers of our language have known other tongues from which they have deliberately or unconsciously stolen words, cadences, or simply been inspired to write better English. Education policy-makers have bemoaned, often justifiably, the quality of foreign language teaching in schools.

Bored students have sat through too many lessons on the French subjunctive or worried about how to pronounce a German vowel with an umlaut, and have left school barely able to order a beer on the other side of the Channel.

But that was a challenge to change the way European languages were taught, not to eliminate them. Starting language studies at the age of 11 was too late. Children need to pick up languages at an early age when they are not self-conscious about making silly mistakes or mispronouncing words.

A defence from Whitehall was to encourage language clubs at primary level.

But if teachers and students know that secondary teaching of foreign languages is not obligatory after the age of 11, there will be little incentive to get serious about the subject at an earlier age.

As a minister, I started to explore with other governments whether they could use the internet to communicate directly with pupils at home as well as in school in a way that was tailored to the pupil's personal interests.

Britain is full of young Europeans working for modest salaries to improve their English. Why are these people not able to enter the classroom and be part of the school culture so that hearing French or Spanish spoken in the corridors and school canteens becomes the norm? Also, the businesses setting up the new academies should take a lead by encouraging foreign language teaching.

At some time in the future, Britain will wake up to what has surely been education policy-makers' worst mistake so far this century. But by then there may be no more university teaching of European languages, and it will be too late.

Denis MacShane Labour MP for Rotherham and former Europe minister, 2001-05

Log-in as an existing print or digital subscriber

Forgotten your subscriber ID?


To access this content and the full TES archive, subscribe now.

View subscriber offers


Get TES online and delivered to your door – for less than the price of a coffee

Save 33% off the cover price with this great subscription offer. Every copy delivered to your door by first-class post, plus full access to TES online and the TES app for just £1.90 per week.
Subscribers also enjoy a range of fantastic offers and benefits worth over £270:

  • Discounts off TES Institute courses
  • Access over 200,000 articles in the TES online archive
  • Free Tastecard membership worth £79.99
  • Discounts with Zipcar,, Virgin Wines and other partners
Order your low-cost subscription today