Top unis agree disadvantaged pupils admissions targets

But elite independent schools concerned about possibility of discrimination against individual pupils 'on the basis of the class they were born into'

Tes Reporter

Teachers 'must be more positive', says lord

The UK's top universities should be halving gaps in the numbers of disadvantaged and advantaged pupils taking up degree places in the next five years, a watchdog has said.

The most selective institutions have agreed tough targets with the Office for Students (OfS) for the next five years as part of attempts to improve access for all would-be students.

News: Teachers told to do more to help poor students into uni

Related: Colleges outstrip grammar schools on university offers

Admissions: Record number of students apply to university

Access to university has been a "postcode lottery" in the past, with young people from some parts of England much less likely to go into higher education, according to the OfS.

The situation is worse among the universities which ask for the highest entry grades, it says.

Currently, pupils from the most advantaged areas of England are more than six times as likely as their less advantaged peers to go to one of the most selective institutions in the country, a new analysis by the OfS has found.

But if these universities meet tough new targets, which are meant to improve access to higher education, then this gulf will shrink over the next five years to less than four times as likely, the regulator has calculated.

OfS chairman Sir Michael Barber said: "The chance to go to university has been something of a postcode lottery, and I welcome the ambitious commitments universities are making to change this state of affairs.

"What is an assumed rite of passage for many young people across the country is often viewed very differently in rural and coastal communities, the industrial heartlands and military towns.

"The North-South divide crops up in many debates around equal opportunities, and higher education is no exception."

He added that in London, 54 per cent of pupils go into higher education, but in the North East of England it is 39 per cent and in the South West it is 37 per cent.

"So this is more than a simple North-South divide," Sir Michael said. "In fact, the South West has the lowest participation rate of any region, while our most elite universities tend to recruit far fewer students from the West Midlands."

Under rules brought in when tuition fees were trebled to a maximum of £9,250 a year, institutions that want to charge the top rates must have access agreements signed off by the OfS.

These agreements contain targets on areas such as recruitment of particular under-represented groups, drop-out rates and gaps in degree achievement between students.

Individual agreements show the commitments universities have made.

For example, Oxford has pledged to cut the ratio of most represented to least-represented groups from around 15 to one to eight to one, while Cambridge has committed to cutting the ratio from around 14 to one to around 6.7 to one.

Chris Millward, OfS director of fair access and participation, said: "There's a real issue about capitalising on the talents across all parts of the country.

"Nobody would say looking at the current profile of people going into the most selective universities that that reflects the talent and potential of students across the country.

"This is really about improving opportunity for people who could benefit from that kind of education and don't currently. And that's a fairness issue."

Mr Millward said that if universities do not meet their pledges, then the regulator will decide whether they have taken enough action to do so.

Universities found to have failed to improve access can face sanctions, including fines.

No institution has yet been fined for this reason.

Mr Millward also said the extent to which there could be "displacement" of more advantaged students will depend on whether universities decide to grow their numbers in order to help improve access.

"I would come back to this is about recognising talent from all backgrounds, and currently lots of students from the parts of the country that are being targeted now in these plans are not recognised," he said.

He said he understood that Oxford and Cambridge were not planning to increase their student numbers, adding: "Again, it would be their own decision about whether they decide to do that.

"Some people have advocated that they should, but inevitably in Oxbridge if they don't grow, then the groups that are very highly represented in those universities will be less represented at the end of this. There's no doubt about that."

Mike Buchanan, executive director of HMC (the Headmasters' and Headmistresses' Conference), said: "We are confident that the exceptional results and soft skills that HMC schools provide will mean that our students will continue to get the university places they wish for in a competitive UK marketplace or at prestigious universities overseas.

"However, care is needed in starting actively to discriminate against individual young people on the basis of the class they were born into. The country needs all its young people to reach their potential if we are to create a bright new future for Britain post-Brexit.

"We urge the government to enable universities and colleges to expand to take as many truly suitable students as necessary, rather than rob some students of a future to award it to others.

"Universities should also look at the increasing numbers of high-paying international students they are accepting, rather than deny places to UK students based on their class."

A University of Oxford spokesman said: "Oxford's admissions process is designed to identify academic potential and passion for a subject.

"More than 69 per cent of undergraduate offers were made to pupils attending state schools, and a record number to those from under-represented backgrounds.

"A highly academically talented student with enthusiasm for their chosen subject has every chance of getting into Oxford, regardless of their background or where they live, and will continue to do so.

"The changes we have brought in, with widespread support across the university and its colleges, have increased and diversified the pool of students applying to and receiving offers from Oxford.

"This year we saw a record of more than 23,600 students apply for just 3,300 places. Greater competition inevitably means more students will be disappointed, but we want the best talent possible for the outstanding
education we offer."

James Turner, chief executive of the Sutton Trust said: “There is some great work underway in universities and a robust focus from OfS on widening access to higher education. 

“But as today’s report shows, there are still significant regional disparities in who gets into the most selective universities. More must be done to tackle these geographical divides, so it is great to see universities setting out ambitious plans to halve the gap between the poorest and wealthiest areas within five years.

"The focus now must be on implementation and on ensuring that these targets are met and real progress is made on a decades-old problem.

“We know that inequalities in higher education go beyond the point of entry, so the focus on closing gaps in dropout rates and degree outcomes is also welcome.

"It is vital that all young people not only have the same opportunities to access higher education, but also to succeed once they get there.”




Register to continue reading for free

It only takes a moment and you'll get access to more news, plus courses, jobs and teaching resources tailored to you

Tes Reporter

Latest stories

Coronavirus and schools: Don't let the vocal critics of teachers get you down, says headteacher Michael Tidd

The nation says thank you to school staff

On National Thank a Teacher Day students and the general public have been sending messages to school staff. Here are some of the best bits
Tes Editorial 23 Jun 2021
Gillian Keegan talks to Tes about the skills bill

Keegan: Government won't 'clear up' after colleges

Apprenticeships and skills minister Gillian Keegan tells Tes why new intervention powers are needed and why the Skills Bill will introduce a 'culture of lifelong learning'
Julia Belgutay 23 Jun 2021