Stop disciplining black students out of the school system

19th May 2016 at 08:45
The lack of belief in children as learners leads to excessive policing of students and a self-fulfilling prophecy

If we viewed students as learners and not uneducable criminals, then we wouldn’t kick them out of schools.

We certainly wouldn’t shuttle children through an adult justice system.

Education’s original sin of not believing children are actually children erodes even the most strident of educators’ belief that all children can learn and should be educated in school (and not disciplined out of it).

Believing in children as learners is why schools should applaud Louisiana Senate Bill 324.

Under the Senate bill, youth arrested for nonviolent crimes would be tried and imprisoned under the juvenile justice system. Sponsored by Sen. J.P. Morrell (D-New Orleans), the bill would raise the legal age in the definition of a delinquent from 17 to 18. This bill should shortly reach Gov. John Bel Edwards for signing.

School to prison pipeline?

The complicity between education and criminal justice systems should be apparent. From a negative view of youth, schools not only adopted no-tolerance policies of the criminal justice system, they often fueled it through suspension and expulsion.

Arrests are often made on the school grounds. Police and Security Resource Officers are becoming hired muscle for teachers. In addition, we issue suspensions as if it helps students graduate. Actually, multiple suspensions increase the likelihood of dropping out of school by 10th grade threefold. This is the same rate at which dropping out of school increases one’s chances of being incarcerated.

At the core of both these horrible sets of policies is the lack of belief in children as learners. Locking up or putting out problems is the antithesis of teaching. Regressive criminal justice policies and harsh school discipline policies are evil cousins that rob black and brown students’ humanity.

What is "willful disobedience"?

According to the Louisiana Department of Education, during the 2013-2014 school year, 13,535 of 61,201 total out-of-school suspensions were due to willful disobedience. Eight thousand willful disobedience suspensions were dispensed to the very young: grades Pre-K to 5. A higher percentage of those suspensions were handed out to black children, who make up 44 percent of Louisiana students but 67 percent of out-of-school suspensions and 68 percent of expulsions.

Willful disobedience is code enforcement for those who believe black kids don’t deserve an education.

Out-of-school discipline obviously doesn’t work for individual students who are suspended or for communities (except for the justice system).

There’s even growing evidence that overwrought suspension is harmful to “well-behaved kids” in school who aren’t disciplined. One study found that more suspensions lowered academic achievement among non-suspended students. In addition, suspension targets black and brown children – the people who need public systems to really care for them.

If you really believe that all children can learn, then you have to believe that you can teach them. The irony of major education groups’ history of blocking such legislation is the subtle admission of an inability to teach and reach students.

In the hood we often say, “If you’re scared, go to church.” (Some regions say, “If you’re scared, call the police,” but that saying wouldn’t work for this particular column.) The point is that if you are ill equipped as an educator to deal with certain situations, ask for support. Don’t put children and communities in peril by projecting one’s teaching inadequacy, fear and youths out in the streets.

The elimination of expulsion and suspension from discipline practices is the work that comes from a true faith that “all children can learn.”

It is said that faith without work is dead. Juvenile justice advocates are giving life to faith by offering an opportunity to apply good work to education’s most sacred saying.

K-12 education groups can act on faith by supporting legislation that can reduce suspension and expulsion.

Schools ought to support this legislation.

End of the line for the bill, but not students

Unfortunately, another bill, House Bill 372, did not get enough votes this week to make it off the house floor. That bill would have given teachers better tools to deal with discipline issues in the classroom, before they escalated. The lack of support from the K-12 community is but another sign that educators really don’t believe all children can learn.

Schools should have supported House Bill 372.

Because the only lesson that is “taught” from out-of-school discipline is how to give up on children.


Dr. Andre Perry is the former founding dean of urban education at Davenport University. He tweets as @andreperryedu.

This story was produced by The Hechinger Report, a nonprofit, independent news website focused on inequality and innovation in education.

Want to keep up with the latest education news and opinion? Follow TES USA on Twitter and like TES USA on Facebook.​



The guide by your side – ensuring you are always up to date with the latest in education.

Get Tes magazine online and delivered to your door. Stay up to date with the latest research, teacher innovation and insight, plus classroom tips and techniques with a Tes magazine subscription.
With a Tes magazine subscription you get exclusive access to our CPD library. Including our New Teachers’ special for NQTS, Ed Tech, How to Get a Job, Trip Planner, Ed Biz Special and all Tes back issues.

Subscribe now