No amount of tech will ever replace the love of a great teacher

7th June 2016 at 10:02
There are no silver bullets in education but love is a good start

Want to keep up with the latest education news and opinion? Follow TES USA on Twitter and like TES USA on Facebook.​​

This year thousands of educators descended on the Bett Show at the Excel in East London. Visitors from around the world toured countless trade stands and listened to some great talks – but what are they after?

This annual quest appears to be, increasingly, in search of effectiveness, rather than the latest shiny new thing. This is a good development. It will always be the case that teaching comes before technology; technology is simply a tool that teachers may use to enhance their practice.

This doesn’t only apply to technology. It is the same with anything new.

My attention was drawn to a recent interview with Carol Dweck. Her work on the Growth Mindset has interested a huge number of teachers. At its heart are two complementary ideas. Praising children for being clever gives them a fixed mindset that good performance is innate and can’t be grown. By contrast, educating children to understand that we can grow abilities, through effort and resilience, helps them thrive.

However, it appears that poor application of this thinking is bothering Professor Dweck.

“Recently, someone asked what keeps me up at night. It’s the fear that the mindset concepts, which grew up to counter the failed self-esteem movement, will be used to perpetuate that movement. In other words, if you want to make students feel good, even if they’re not learning, just praise their effort!”

She is clear. Growth Mindset isn’t just about effort. Equally, identifying a fixed mindset is not a justification for a student not learning. Parents who praise effort but react to their child’s mistakes as problems are missing the point. The Growth Mindset is about learning from mistakes and unlocking learning.

Like the use of technology in the classroom, applying new thinking, such as the Growth Mindset or flipped learning, needs reflection and training. There are no silver bullets, and any visitors to BETT should never forget that when being wowed by the great salespeople in their lovely corporate T-shirts.

But I also think we all need to reflect on effectiveness.

It feels like in the UK we are trapped into the idea that effectiveness is only what is culturally deemed rigorous, and what is measurable.

All of this contrasts with some of the commentary from the USA. A recent survey of school superintendents shows 77 percent agree that students’ level of hope for their own future is a good measure of school effectiveness. While surveying students is perfectly measurable, I suspect this wouldn’t pass the rigor test here in England.

I then noticed this New York Times article, "How measurement fails doctors and teachers". This last passage really struck me:

Avedis Donabedian, a professor at the University of Michigan’s School of Public Health, was a towering figure in the field of quality measurement. He developed what is known as Donabedian’s triad, which states that quality can be measured by looking at outcomes (how the subjects fared), processes (what was done) and structures (how the work was organized). In 2000, shortly before he died, he was asked about his view of quality. What this hard-nosed scientist answered is shocking at first, then somehow seems obvious.

“The secret of quality is love,” he said.

Once I got over my cultural reaction to write this off as hippie nonsense, I thought about it. It is obvious. What we want from public service is more love. We want teachers who love teaching because they love unlocking learning, and love helping children grow. 

But how do we measure love?

At BETT next year there very well may be artificial intelligence that can teach the times tables, and test them, without humans. But will there be love? Our worst fears of a dystopian future, of humans competing with machines, is loveless. As we continue to seek out the next thing that works in teaching we should keep it human, and cherish the love.

Lord Knight is chief education adviser to TES' parent company, TES Global, and a former minister of state for schools. He tweets as @jimpknight.


The guide by your side – ensuring you are always up to date with the latest in education.

Get Tes magazine online and delivered to your door. Stay up to date with the latest research, teacher innovation and insight, plus classroom tips and techniques with a Tes magazine subscription.
With a Tes magazine subscription you get exclusive access to our CPD library. Including our New Teachers’ special for NQTS, Ed Tech, How to Get a Job, Trip Planner, Ed Biz Special and all Tes back issues.

Subscribe now