Instead of caging learning, lectures can set it free

The popularity of YouTube and TED Talks shows this cost-effective method of teaching is ripe for revival
3rd February 2017, 12:00am
Magazine Article Image

Share

Instead of caging learning, lectures can set it free

https://www.tes.com/magazine/archived/instead-caging-learning-lectures-can-set-it-free

Google the words “further education” and the search engine may well finish your sentence with “financial crisis”.

News headlines frequently warn of a looming funding crisis in the sector and recent forecasts suggest that as many as 70 colleges are “financially inadequate”.

The government has instigated 37 area reviews of college provision to make the sector more efficient and financially resilient. FE and sixth-form college commissioners, meanwhile, argue that there is significant scope for greater efficiency in the sector, in a way that “frees up resources to deliver high-quality education and training”.

How exactly can delivery costs be cut, then, without sacrificing educational quality?

One answer is to introduce (or reintroduce or expand) the “lecture” format, as a means of teaching large groups of learners with fewer staff and at a lower cost.

As well as being cost-effective, lectures - as opposed to classroom-based sessions and tutorials - are also a good use of precious learning space, enabling colleges to reduce the cost of their estate.

So why, if lectures are a cost-effective means of teaching, do so few appear on learners’ timetables in FE? It may be because the lecture has become synonymous with didactic teaching of the worst kind: laborious, long-winded teacher-talk leading to passive, not active, learning. But does it have to be this way? Do lectures have to be wholly didactic and, what’s more, is didacticism really the poor relation of active learning?

Watch and learn

Students like and learn from online “lectures” all the time. They watch YouTube videos that explain how to apply make-up, bake cakes, build impressive structures on Minecraft, perfect their golf swing, and so on. They watch TED Talks, too, which inspire them on topics ranging from “Your body language shapes who you are” to “How to spot a liar”.

Students rely on quality instruction in their private lives: they watch online lectures, learn from them, then emulate what they’ve seen and heard, challenging themselves to improve by increments. So why not enable them to do likewise at college?

Timetable regular lectures as a means of instructing learners on new knowledge and skills, then follow this up with planned opportunities for independent practice and structured self-assessment.

Spark critical thinking

The benefits of the lecture format do not begin and end with cost-cutting. Lectures - like YouTube videos - can teach learners the art of attention. They can show them how to listen respectfully and carefully to others; something that may be in short supply in an age of instant gratification.

Lectures are also an exercise in mindfulness because learners must be attentive - active not passive - if they are to follow the lecturer’s argument and act on its central premise in their own work. Lectures can provide learners with their first crucial step towards developing a capacity for critical thinking, because a good lecture offers not a simple recitation of facts but the careful construction of an argument.

Note-making (rather than note-taking) is also an art form worth learning, and lectures provide plentiful opportunities for this. Participating in lectures and developing note-making skills enable learners to reason, analyse, and weigh statements and arguments, developing a sense of curiosity and wonder.

Foster belonging

The lecture format also gives whole cohorts a shared experience: each learner feels a part of the group and knows exactly what is expected of them. Lectures can make studying in large groups a positive experience, so that learners feel valued and cared for.

They can help learners to gain a sense of identity as a member of a bigger cohort; they can also enable learners to see the myriad links that exist between different topics, modules and subject areas.

In this way, lectures can help learners to see and appreciate the bigger picture, which, in turn, can provide both intrinsic and extrinsic motivation - gifting learners the desire as well as the need to learn.

Make lectures inspiring

Students are more likely to engage with lectures and find them inspiring if they are explicitly linked to their experiences of online learning and to the way in which they apply in practice what they have learned by watching YouTube or TED Talks.

Students need to know that they are similarly expected to take learning away from a lecture that is given in college and apply it in practice. As such, lecture material should - where possible - be active rather than passive, applied rather than theoretical.

Lectures can also be inspiring if they arouse students’ curiosity and interest in a subject, and motivate them to do a lot of reading and studying outside the lecture theatre.

In short, the lecture should be a catalyst - a trigger - for learning, not its sole means.

The lecture, then, is certainly one solution to the ongoing financial crisis faced by the FE sector, providing a way of ensuring high-quality education at a lower cost.

Moreover, the lecture replicates a mode of learning already popular with learners in their private lives, thus helping to inspire and engage them.


Matt Bromley is an education leader, writer, consultant, speaker and trainer @mj_bromley

You need a Tes subscription to read this article

Subscribe now to read this article and get other subscriber-only content:

  • Unlimited access to all Tes magazine content
  • Exclusive subscriber-only stories
  • Award-winning email newsletters

Already a subscriber? Log in

You need a subscription to read this article

Subscribe now to read this article and get other subscriber-only content, including:

  • Unlimited access to all Tes magazine content
  • Exclusive subscriber-only stories
  • Award-winning email newsletters
Recent
Most read
Most shared