He claims, for instance, that "even the best tools don't emancipate".
I think he will find, however, a large number of learners, particularly those with special needs, for whom ICT has been just that: emancipatory.
Nor is the interpersonal teaching which he espouses always so satisfactory. There are plenty of lessons where the questions posed by teachers expect a very limited range of answers and where pupils are rarely encouraged to engage in the kind of educative conversations he envisages.
Even more widespread are lessons where pupils will not risk active participation for fear of their peers' reactions or of being wrong. It is in such situations that ICT can provide an infinitely patient, non-threatening and empowering environment.
As with all tools, it is how they are used that is crucial. That is why a properly educated teaching force which really understands the possibilities and the limitations of ICT is so essential.
Director of communications anddevelopment
National Association for Teaching English
Fern House, High Street