Financiers want to run 2,000 state schools - with bonuses

Staff and directors to profit from success under John Lewis-style plan

David Marley

An education group established by two City financiers has unveiled the most ambitious plans yet of the academies programme in England - with a target of running more than 2,000 schools and introducing annual John Lewis-style bonuses for all staff.

Clarendon Academies, which counts Martin Stephen, the former high master of St Paul's, as chair of its advisory board, wants a far bigger share of the market than existing sponsors, which typically operate up to 20 schools.

By running at least 10 per cent of state schools, Clarendon, which has held lengthy discussions with the Westminster government's Department for Education (DfE), believes it would generate financial surpluses that would be ploughed back into education and teachers' pay. Longer term, the set-up also allows those behind the project to receive bonuses if standards improve.

Clarendon has laid out its strategy as ministers focus on academy conversion for significant numbers of primaries that are considered to be underperforming. The first 100 such conversions were confirmed by the government last week.

Under the proposals, all of Clarendon's schools would be modelled on the John Lewis Partnership, with staff considered part-owners of the business and taking an equal share of surplus cash that might be generated by efficiently running large numbers of schools.

While the group accepts that it would have to start small, its plan is predicated on rapid expansion. "The next evolutionary leap forward in the academies programme is to deliver tremendous economies of scale and deliver something that is much more efficient," said Dr Stephen.

Clarendon would, in time, expect to pay staff up to 14 per cent of their salary as a bonus each year. By offering higher pay and making teachers partners, the chain believes that staff would have greater commitment to seeing schools succeed.

The two men behind Clarendon, Nigel a Brassard, an investment banker, and Edwin Richards, a private equity expert, insist that their motivation is to improve educational standards, not turn a profit. However, the model they are promoting pushes the boundaries of the current ban on schools being run to make money.

Under Clarendon's model, a business will be established to provide educational services, including all teaching staff. An independent charitable trust will be set up separately to sponsor academies, but it has already been agreed that the sponsor will buy its services from the business.

The group will also bid to run state schools still under local authority control or academies that have other sponsors but decide they need extra support. Mr a Brassard said the issue of profit was "irrelevant" to Clarendon and that there would be no "seepage" of money into the hands of shareholders.

`A vanity project'

Russell Hobby, general secretary of heads' union the NAHT, said that any organisation would struggle to deliver quality education on the scale proposed.

"The existing chains are finding it very hard to grow by a dozen schools as they realise that running schools is much more difficult than it might look," he said. "This feels like a vanity project or a business proposition, not a vision for education."

Mary Bousted, general secretary of education union the ATL, said the idea of any group running 2,000 schools was "horrifying" and would skew the education system. "There is also no evidence that teachers want to be shareholders in schools," she said.

Register to continue reading for free

It only takes a moment and you'll get access to more news, plus courses, jobs and teaching resources tailored to you

David Marley

Latest stories


‘Dear teachers: you have been amazing’

Looking back on the past year, school staff should remind themselves that they have been doing an extraordinary job in extraordinary times, says Geoff Barton
Geoff Barton 23 Jul 2021