Firms queue up as Gove makes moves towards for-profit schools

Education providers welcome hints of financial gains from free schools

Richard Vaughan

Education providers have thrown their weight behind Michael Gove after he announced that free schools could be run for profit if the Conservatives secure a second term in office.

The Westminster education secretary made his first public admission that he felt schools could "move toward" being run for profit when giving evidence at the Leveson inquiry into press ethics.

While it is unlikely that the move could happen under the coalition, Mr Gove said that the quality of state education would be "augmented by extending the range of people involved in its provision".

His comments provoked outrage from teaching unions, but were supported by Sir David Bell, who until this year was education's highest-ranking civil servant. He said that the profit motive should be trialled in some of the country's most underperforming schools before it was rolled out elsewhere.

"A good place to start would be where all other state interventions have failed, where you have had a successive round of failures and you have tried everything else," he said. "In those circumstances it is quite hard to make a moral argument against profit. If you want to make a case for this, start where it's toughest and let's see whether the profit motive generates an improvement that otherwise has not been created."

Teaching unions have long claimed that the free school policy would lead to the "privatisation" of state education, with an influx of for-profit companies. NUT deputy general secretary Kevin Courtney said that free school providers in Sweden had made profits by employing unqualified teachers and feared that schools here would follow suit.

Trevor Averre-Beeson, founder of Lilac Sky Schools - an approved academy sponsor that runs the management of two schools for profit and is to take over two more from September - said that numerous organisations would be interested in establishing for-profit schools. "It seems completely appropriate that if we do something successful, such as raising pupil attainment or getting a school out of special measures, we would get a bonus on a performance-related contract," Mr Averre-Beeson said. "And if we don't, we would get a fine. I think it makes the running of schools more accountable."

A leading private school provider, which did not want to be named, said there needed to be more flexibility in education to allow schools to raise money. "The issue is about quality; when you buy a product you don't ask at the point of sale where the profits go, you ask whether the product is any good," the source said.

Rachel Wolf, director of free schools charity the New Schools Network, backed the move towards profit, claiming it had to be considered if free schools were to expand.

Schools are already allowed to employ educational management organisations (EMOs) to take care of their day-to-day running and these can be profit- making companies. This is the model used by Lilac Sky Schools and also allowed the Breckland Free School in Suffolk to employ the for-profit Swedish provider, Internationella Engelska Skolan.

But author and journalist Toby Young, whose West London Free School was one of the first to open last year, said that this model should go further and allow EMOs to establish their own profit-making free schools, as is the case in Sweden.

Stats for free schools:

24 - free schools are open

79 - free schools have been approved to open in September

330 - free school applications have been made via the New Schools Network to open in 2013

100 - or more are expected to be approved in November

pound;337 million - was spent on free schools up to April 2012.

Register to continue reading for free

It only takes a moment and you'll get access to more news, plus courses, jobs and teaching resources tailored to you

Richard Vaughan

Richard has been writing about politics, policy and technology in education for nearly five years after joining TES in 2008. He joined TES from the building press having been a reporter and then later news editor at the Architects’ Journal. Before then he studied at Cardiff University’s school of journalism. Richard can be found tweeting at @richardvaughan1

Find me on Twitter @RichardVaughan1

Latest stories

News article image

Berridge: how we will weed out the ‘bad apples’

In an effort to secure a good school for every child, the government is clarifying its guidance on when it can prohibit someone from running a school, says Baroness Berridge
Baroness Elizabeth Berridge 28 Jul 2021