Get back to Islington
Share
Get back to Islington
https://www.tes.com/magazine/archive/get-back-islington
Coincidentally a conference in Northern Ireland, which retains secondary school segregation in more than a denominational sense, heard a more accurate summary of the position from Linda Croxford of Edinburgh University (page four). Under comprehensive education in the three countries of the UK which adopted it, pupil achievement has risen significantly.
The successes are greatest where the comprehensive approach is most firmly embedded - in Scotland and Wales. England (in common with only the Scottish caital) has a large number of independent schools creaming off abler pupils, mainly from middle-class families. Therefore the problems identified by Mr Blair, which have prompted so many of the Islington dinner-party set to bypass comprehensive schools, are more pronounced in areas where social and educational segregation is greatest.
The Prime Minister is right to argue against a “one size fits all” constriction within comprehensive schools. Fortunately, the attention now given to individual needs makes that less of a worry than it was a decade or more ago. Lack of resources continues to narrow choice: the take-up of Advanced Highers will be an indicator in many schools. But social inclusivity is not, or should not be, synonymous with uniformity. The danger in Tony Blair’s half-informed speech is that it gives succour to those who still question the comprehensive principle.
You've reached your limit of free articles this month. Subscribe for £1 per month for three months and get: