Payment by results sparks opposition;Briefing;International

7th May 1999, 1:00am

Share

Payment by results sparks opposition;Briefing;International

https://www.tes.com/magazine/archive/payment-results-sparks-oppositionbriefinginternational
JAPAN

‘Effective’ teachers are to be given extra cash, reports Michael Fitzpatrick

Japanese state schools are set to introduce performance pay for the first time, despite opposition from teachers.

Under proposals made by the Tokyo Metropolitan Board of Education, “effective” teachers will be rewarded financially for their ability, enthusiasm and achievement following a personal assessment by their headteacher. The rating will take into account the opinions of senior teachers, parents and students and self-evaluations.

The Tokyo proposals, for an education authority covering a population of 27 million, will link evaluation to accelerated promotion or pay rises. Heads will award teachers an A, B or C grade based on their evaluation of teachers’ performances. Teachers rated as especially able would be rewarded with extra pay.

Noboru Ura, secretary general of the Tokyo Metropolitan Teachers’ Union, is against the changes. He said teachers would be forced to compete against each other, just as children have for a place at a good school. “I’m worried that it could undermine co-operative relations among teachers and weaken each school’s individual educational strengths.”

A panel reporting to the Tokyo board of education recommended that teachers should be rated by three criteria - ability, enthusiasm or attitude, and achievement. Characters and personality would not come under inspection. Principals would visit classes as part of the assessment, the report said.

The present teacher evaluation scheme, introduced in Tokyo in 1958, is seen merely as a formality and is largely ignored because unions strongly oppose it.

Some private schools already grade teachers, based on evaluations by students. Educationists say such a trend is growing, given the heightened competition for an ever-shrinking pool of students.

Education writer Shuichi Fujimori said the feedback from students does not influence teaching content because that is decided predominantly by the ministry of education. “In consequence, the teachers cannot perform their own initiatives,” he says.

Tokyo’s teachers may not accept such changes without protest. Last year more than 2,100 teachers from the Tokyo Metropolitan High School Teachers’ Union staged a one-hour strike against the metropolitan government’s decision to give more authority to headteachers. Present administration policies givepanels more authority than school principals.

Want to keep reading for free?

Register with Tes and you can read two free articles every month plus you'll have access to our range of award-winning newsletters.

Keep reading for just £1 per month

You've reached your limit of free articles this month. Subscribe for £1 per month for three months and get:

  • Unlimited access to all Tes magazine content
  • Exclusive subscriber-only stories
  • Award-winning email newsletters
Recent
Most read
Most shared