The point of sums
When I was working in a primary classroom, the teacher told the pupils the digits moved and demonstrated this on a place-value grid by moving an acetate overlay. The decimal point, being a point of reference, only indicated the position of the whole numbers and bits of the whole. I have seen other teachers illustrating the movement of the decimal point using arrows.
Which method should I use to help the pupils I support? And if the maths teacher is teaching incorrectly, should I tell him?
A. Full marks to your primary colleagues. The digits move when multiplying or dividing and the decimal point is only a point of reference. To demonstrate this with digit cards, the point stays still and the digits move around it.
I am sure your school has provided a maths resource pack. This could include pieces of acetate, an acetate pen and a piece of laminated card with the place value labelled as shown below.
To use this to demonstrate how the digits move when multiplying by powers of 10, overlay the acetate then physically move it. If pupils are not sure why you do this, use a simpler number such as 0.2 and get them to count on 10 lots of 0.2 to get 2.
I remember the frustration I felt when I discovered parents were telling their children that to multiply by 10 you added a nought. This is not the case when there is a decimal in the question; for example, 10 x 0.2 would become 0.20, rather than 2. This would confuse the pupil - and “unteaching” is far more difficult than teaching.
Telling the maths teacher he is teaching something incorrectly is a difficult issue, particularly as there is a need to be diplomatic. I would tell him about your confusion and suggest that you thought the reason he moved the decimal point was because it was an easier way to manipulate the cards. Ask him to include in his explanation that it’s the digits that move, demonstrating the difficulty of manipulating the cards and so showing why he is moving the decimal point.
Hopefully, this poem will help:
Point of reference
What happens when
You multiply by 10?
Really you thought
That you add a nought?
Don’t sing such a song
You really are wrong!
So, you need me to prove
The point doesn’t move.
I have a suggestion
To answer your question;
What you already know
Is that a point can’t grow.
Let us try then,
Twenty times 10.
This makes the figure
Get 10 times bigger;
Moving left, one place,
which, is always the case.
The rule we consult,
Two hundred the result.
This then proves
The point never moves.
But, I just taught
You don’t add a nought!
Let’s make it plain;
We’ll try this again.
What about 0.2?
Does it still hold true
When we multiply by 10?
Can we say this, then,
It moves left a place
Which is always the case.
You certainly know
That this equals two.
Doesn’t this then prove
It’s the digits that move?
The decimal point
Is a point of reference.
Q. During a discussion in the staffroom about computer memory, we found ourselves asking what came after gigabytes. Have you any idea?
A. For those who might like to use this as a basis of discussion of the use of standard form, the following list provides the name of the memory unit, its abbreviation and the number of information bits:
Byte (B): 8 (8 x 100)
Kilobyte (kB); 8,000 (8 x 103)
Megabyte (MB): 8,000,000 (8 x 106)
Gigabyte (GB): 8,000,000,000 (8 x 109)
Terabyte (TB): 8,000,000,000,000 (8 x 1012)
Petabyte (PB): 8,000,000,000,000,000 (8 x 1015)
Exabyte (EB): 8,000,000,000,000,000,000 (8 x 1018)
A poster in the staffroom might help and you could have a bet as to when the next measurement will become a natural part of our language. Which department will be closest to predicting the date when PC World talks of terabytes?.
Keep reading for just £1 per month
You've reached your limit of free articles this month. Subscribe for £1 per month for three months and get:
- Unlimited access to all Tes magazine content
- Exclusive subscriber-only stories
- Award-winning email newsletters