'The poorer you are, the fewer subject choices you get'

Shrinking choices are having a serious impact on students – it's time for the denial to stop, argues Barry Black

Barry Black

subject choices in Scotland: why less definitely isn't more for poorer pupils

As readers will be all too aware, subject choice in schools is a major issue in Scottish education. Earlier this month, investigative journalism website The Ferret published findings of my research, which adds further weight to the growing evidence that those who are worse off in Scotland have a more constrained choice of subjects.

The research, whose full findings can be seen in the article, compares the average number of Scottish Qualifications Authority (SQA) entries per pupil at a school with the proportion of pupils on free school meals. The data demonstrates what has been a growing concern for some time: pupils in schools with higher rates of deprivation have fewer numbers of subjects available and a lower rate of attainment.  

My research shows that schools with more than 40 per cent of pupils on free school meals offer nearly 10 per cent fewer subjects across the senior phase than schools where the figure is between 0 and 10 per cent. The national average for subject entries across S4 to S6 is 13.97. In the most affluent schools, the number is 14.25, and in the most deprived it is only 12.94.

Subject choices: Narrowing choice has 'profound implications' for pupils

First Minister's Questions: Sturgeon grilled over pupils' subject choices

Background: Claims about improving attainment 'not fully accurate'

Curriculum for Excellence: What does data really say about Scotland's curriculum?

While the data highlights a large disparity in S4, the most significant difference exists in S5, where there is a gap of nearly an entire subject: 4.27 compared with 3.42.

Not only do pupils in more affluent schools have a larger number of subject options but they are also more likely to pass them.

Just over half of pupils from the poorest schools achieve one Higher or equivalent by the time they leave school – a huge difference to the nearly three-quarters of pupils in the most affluent schools.

Crucially, while 14 per cent of Scotland’s pupils are on free school meals, there are 77 schools where this figure is more than 20 per cent. In numbers of senior phase subject choices, and National 5 and Higher attainment, these schools are well behind the national average.

This is the latest in an increasing body of research, which includes a Scottish Parliament report, showing one of two things. First, there has been a narrowing of the number of subject choices available in schools since the implementation of the new curriculum. Second, this narrowing is having a bigger impact in more deprived schools. 

It is clear that policy solutions are needed to tackle these issues. Before these can be properly explored, however, there needs to be an acceptance from policymakers that there is a problem. Far too often, those responsible for our education system rebut the evidence by conflating what is meant by "subject choice", or by simply denying that this is their experience.

There has to be more serious engagement with the research and an appreciation of the serious impact these issues can have on young people. The current review of the senior phase is the perfect opportunity to decide how some of these unintended consequences can be overcome.

We know subject choices have a profound impact on young people and their future options. This research adds to the evidence that, in Scotland, pupils in schools in the poorest areas have fewer choices – a situation that must be rectified.

Barry Black is a postgraduate education researcher at the University of Glasgow. He tweets @BarryBlackNE

Register to continue reading for free

It only takes a moment and you'll get access to more news, plus courses, jobs and teaching resources tailored to you

Latest stories

Ministers seem to think schools are wasting money - in fact, schools are experts in cutting costs, says James Bowen

Why international teachers should receive financial CPD

There's a lot to learn working in another country - not least the financial situation and how to use your money wisely, which is why perhaps a CPD session or two would be a worthwhile investment
David Keating 30 Jul 2021