‘I’ll tell you what isn’t helpful at all: telling children with mental health problems that they’re namby-pamby’

13th June 2016 at 16:28
Youth mental health
​The backclash against the growing interest in youth mental health problems has begun. We must not give these critics credence, writes one leading campaigner

I have a friend whose second decade on this planet was defined entirely by anorexia nervosa. She spent her secondary school years in various in-patient units over in the USA. She is now in her thirties and pretty much recovered, but she requires ongoing support from time to time.

She went to see a psychiatrist here in London last week who told her: “I can see anorexia is far behind you. I don’t even have to put you on the scale."

For a person with medical qualifications to have so little idea about what defines an eating disorder and what it is appropriate to say to someone with a history of mental illness defies belief. For, whilst my friend technically has a "healthy" body mass index, eating disorders happen in the mind. They cannot always be seen.

Over half term I had lunch with my cousin, who works with children with autism and is one of the cleverest and most intuitive people I know. After I left uni, whilst I was in the throes of my own eating disorder, I stayed with her for about six months.

“I didn’t know,” she told me. “You hid it so well. I knew something was wrong with you emotionally, but I wouldn’t have guessed it was bulimia.”

That’s the problem with trying to "symptom spot" mental illnesses using physical criteria. Self-harm is the same – the harming of oneself physically is a symptom, the cause lives in the mind. Furthermore, self-harm isn’t, contrary to popular belief, restricted to cutting: a recent investigation by the BBC found that an increasing number of young women were "self-poisoning" by, amongst other things, drinking huge quantities of alcohol with the intention of causing themselves physical damage.

One of the questions I am most commonly asked by parents and teachers is: "Where is the line between common-or-garden teenage angst and a mental health issue?" What they want to know is, "When should I start worrying?" That’s an incredibly difficult question to answer, because it can differ from person to person – after all, our mental health happens in the context of our unique circumstances and personality.

It’s probably easier to discuss what definitely isn’t helpful, and that is the tack taken by the director of the Institute of Ideas, Claire Fox; the associated online magazine Spiked and professional troll Katie Hopkins. Namely, telling young people to shut up, soldier on and stop being so (direct quote from Fox) "namby pamby".

In a series of increasingly irate articles for the Right-wing press this week, Fox has accused today’s young people of being "feeble"; a "generation snowflake" who simply cannot deal with their ideas being challenged. She reached this conclusion, apparently, after telling a group of A-level students that "rape isn’t the worst thing that can happen to a woman" and being inexplicably surprised by their subsequent distress.

Spiked magazine, similarly, denies that there is any issue with young people’s mental health. Assistant editor Ella Whelan expressed incredulity that adults are suddenly being expected to take the concerns of teenagers, whom she calls “crisp-eating mirror obsessives, seriously.

“Apparently, the teenage cry of ‘I’m depressed’ no longer means 'I’m bored and want attention' – it means ‘Book me in to see a therapist or you’re being negligent,’" she sneers.

Resentment towards young people

Mental health is getting a lot of media attention at the moment, so I suppose this sort of backlash was inevitable (even if it does make my skin crawl because of the transparent lack of any kind of compassion, humanity or common sense).

Attitudes such as Fox’s and Whelan’s belong in an era when people said, "I was bullied and it never did me any harm." Such attitudes reveal the speaker to be someone who believes people in emotional distress are "faking it" and will one day be grateful for the adversity. These attitudes are also, I believe, often motivated by resentment caused by the misguided belief that today’s young people "have it better".

Saying that, "One day you’ll look back on this time when you were slashing your thigh to ribbons, were taunted daily about your disability or you despised the sight of yourself, and be grateful that it helped you develop a thick skin," isn’t a terribly useful argument either for young people enduring mental illness, or the teachers and parents who look after them. 

The only sure-fire way to spot mental health issues when they are in their embryonic stages (and are therefore eminently more curable) is to make it acceptable and normal for everyone to talk about how they feel. Distress is a completely normal and healthy emotion (particularly, I might add, when the subject at hand is something as emotive as rape) and we shouldn’t shy away from allowing young people to express it.

If we exorcise our emotions at the time we feel them, we can move on. If we are told our behaviour is "attention-seeking", that we should think about people who have "real" problems or, worse still, that showing vulnerability makes us "feeble", we will push our feelings to one side. However, emotions, like all energy, can never be destroyed. Ignoring them doesn’t make them go away. Instead, they fester and become toxic, until one day our stress bucket overflows.

There are early symptoms of mental illness and they include low self-esteem, dramatic mood changes, behaving in an anti-social way and obsessively comparing oneself with others. You’ll note, however, that this list also sounds a lot like "being a teenager" and I suppose in a roundabout way this might have been the point that Whelan was clumsily attempting to make. The problem is that she belongs to a huge swathe of people I have encountered who apparently immediately get amnesia on their 21st birthday, forgetting what it was like to be a child or teenager and to experience these things first-hand. I, conversely, cannot help but reflect on how great it would have been if the full spectrum of human emotion had been normalised when I was young, so that I didn’t come to associate "strength" with stoicism and consequently develop the anxiety disorder I still struggle with today.

Often, the only true way to know if someone has a mental illness is to create an environment where they can tell you how they feel without fear of judgment. 

Natasha Devon is the former government mental health champion for schools and founder of the Body Gossip Education Programme and the Self-Esteem Team. She tweets as @NatashaDevonMBE

Want to keep up with the latest education news and opinion? Follow TES on Twitter and like TES on Facebook


Related Content

Get TES online and delivered to your door – for less than the price of a coffee

Save 33% off the cover price with this great subscription offer. Every copy delivered to your door by first-class post, plus full access to TES online and the TES app for just £1.90 per week.
Subscribers also enjoy a range of fantastic offers and benefits worth over £270:

  • Discounts off TES Institute courses
  • Access over 200,000 articles in the TES online archive
  • Free Tastecard membership worth £79.99
  • Discounts with Zipcar, Buyagift.com, Virgin Wines and other partners
Order your low-cost subscription today