Skip to main content

Supply staff may get extra pay

As a European directive proposes new benefits for temporary workers, an agency warns of a teacher shortfall. Warwick Mansell reports.

AT least 24,000 supply teachers in Britain could benefit from European Union reforms aimed at improving the pay and conditions of temporary staff.

Recruitment agencies could be forced to put them on the same rates as permanent teachers - and provide pensions and holiday pay.

The directive, reportedly due to be published next month, is designed to give up to 6.5 million temporary workers across the EU the same pay and conditions rights as long-term staff in comparable jobs.

Temporary staff recruited by councils are paid daily rates on the same scale as permanent employees, but there are no such rules for the 24,000 teachers working for employment agencies.

Some supply teachers are now on a better daily wage than their long-term colleagues but unions have long argued that, for many, rates are worse and include neither pensions nor holiday pay.

There is no guarantee the proposal will make it to the British statute book, as it still has to make it through the European council and EU Parliament. If approved, it would become UK law, possibly by late 2004.

Graham Clayton, senior solicitor at the National Union of Teachers, said:

"A European directive would be very welcome for teachers. It could result in the kind of conditions of employment for supply teachers which we have been campaigning for over the past 10 years."

But Diane Sinclair of the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development said that the move would damage the flexibility of businesses to set pay and conditions for agency workers.

Bob Wicks, chairman of the education division of the Recruitment and Employment Confederation, which represents 60 supply companies, said: "No one forces anyone to work as a supply teacher and many value the freedom and flexibility that goes with it."

The move came as a leading recruitment agency warned this week that schools could lose the services of 2,000 supply teachers a week under changes to the system for criminal records checks.

Select Education said that the introduction of the Criminal Records Bureau on March 1 would lead to a six-week delay in placing temporary staff in schools. Under the new system, all police checks will have to be carried out before anyone can teach in a school.

Meanwhile, TES enquiries have revealed that at least three supply agencies are making more than pound;3 million-a-year profit, with directors receiving bonuses of anything from pound;22,000 to pound;616,000.

According to the last available figures, Protocol Teachers (formerly Spring), made a profit of pound;8.7m on a pound;34m turnover; while Teaching Personnel made pound;3.6m on a pound;14m turnover, with directors each awarded an average of pound;37,000.

TimePlan, the agency at the centre of the Amy Gehring controversy, made pound;5m on a turnover of pound;22m, with its three directors awarded an average of pound;617,000.

The company with the largest recorded turnover was Select, at pound;62m, although it could not provide its profit figures.

Log in or register for FREE to continue reading.

It only takes a moment and you'll get access to more news, plus courses, jobs and teaching resources tailored to you