The brilliance of bad ideas
Professor John MacBeath is reported as saying "if at first you fail, try again, fail better!" - a phrase located on a teacher's classroom wall in Govan (TESS, 15 July). And in the final episode of The Apprentice, winner Tom Pellereau admitted: "I was on the losing team in eight of the tasks!"
Alan Sugar's young business partner, who has a first-class masters degree in mechanical engineering, attributed his success to being dyslexic and credited it with helping him: "Dyslexia has always been a massive positive for me . I was better at certain things than other people. If I had an idea, I could basically make it in my brain, I could visualise it. I could start, spin it around, I could look at it and work out how it could be made."
As Jack Foster states in his book How to Get Ideas (1996), "goal achievement may be linear but, with ideas, one point should not follow the next. Great sideways leaps matter." Peter Senge, of the Massachusetts Institute of Technnology, says: "Really deep thinking is about continually moving back and forward between thinking and action."
Tom's philosophy was that the big picture was very important and he put into practice the basic elements of co-operative learning: socially, he reached consensus of opinion by using the "rock, paper, scissors" technique and he recognised the importance of "turn-taking", by putting his hand up and waiting to be heard, which enabled him to make an individual contribution towards the academic task. He was, as the show's host, Dara O'Briain, stated, "tremendously well mannered". He portrayed all the characteristics of "a responsible citizen, an effective contributor, a successful learner and a confident individual".
How could practitioners emulate Tom's success? Well, his identity and the principles and values that underpin it are critical, but in the final task, he relayed the three elements of practice to his experience. He was:
reflective: why am I doing this? ("I want the buyer to notice my concept");
descriptive: what did I do? ("I said the box had to be handed over personally");
evaluative: how well did I perform under the circumstances? ("I won major contracts").
Tom also cited Thomas Edison as his inspiration - the same Edison who prompted Foster to write: "As with Thomas Edison and his experiments with lightbulbsrubber, bad ideas are no more than part of the elimination process for the creation of good ideas."
Donna English, seconded principal teacher, inclusion support team, Clackmannanshire.