Don't knock their effort
As the teacher responsible for the lesson that led to the photograph he ridicules, I feel obliged to defend the pupils he slights. Given the fact that Mr Noble has no personal knowledge of the boys whose work he flippantly quotes, nor of the risk they took in writing such statements, what right or qualification does he have to comment on the profundity of the statements the boys chose to write on their T-shirts?
Scoring a point at the expense of another undermines self-esteem and is particularly distasteful when it involves a teacher at the expense of a pupil. At the risk of further increasing Mr Noble's negativity regarding the use of quotations, I would remind him that "a child's creativity is nurtured by warmth and the positive approval of significant adults in his life".
Jackie Purdie 55 Grantully Drive, Kelvindale, Glasgow