How much do boys really need fathers?

20th April 2007 at 01:00
Not that much, according to Oliver James, who exposes the origins of the myth that fatherless boys end up as part of a criminal underclass

Fatherless feral boys... lack of male primary school teachers... crisis of masculinity... blah-di-blah-di-blah. Other than in the Daily Mail, that learned scientific journal, where's the evidence that a boy needs a male figure in the home to turn out sane and solvent? It was Charles Murray, the right-wing American ideologue, strongly promoted by The Sunday Times in the 1980s, who set the "blame father-absence" ball rolling.

Correlating the rise in crime with the increase in single parents, he blamed the emergence of an underclass on dads doing a bunk. Never mind that there was no underclass (he merely re-labelled social class V with this catchy appellation), or that poverty and divorce were the real causes.

Norman Dennis, the Fabian, continued down the same line in applying the theory to Brits in the 1990s, based on a misreading of two longitudinal studies.

In fact, when I went back to them, they did not prove father absence was causing crime. That children of divorced parents are twice as likely to be screwed up in almost every respect is true. But that does not prove a son needs a parent with a willy.

Susan Golombok has found no diminution of masculinity or increase in criminality among sons brought up by two lesbian parents - willy-absence made no difference. Admittedly, her study has its flaws but the same has been found in American ones. From a different tack, a British study of 411 boys from low-income homes shows that dad presenceabsence is not in itself crucial.

Those with a father who died were half as likely to become criminal adults as ones whose dad pushed off; if their mum died rather than their dad, they were nine times more at risk - mum seems more important than dad. What is more, there was no difference between boys from disharmonious homes that remained intact and ones that broke up.

Evolutionary psychological theories - rightly pilloried as symptoms of Selfish Capitalist Neo-Conservatism in The Trap, Adam Curtis's recent BBC2 series - imply that sons need a willy-possessing parent.

But you only have to go to Copenhagen or Shanghai to realise that this is chauvinistic (in both senses of the word) ideology, not science. In Denmark, by Sex and the City standards, men are not men and women are not women. There are no alpha males clubbing each other over the head to decide who gets the sabre-toothed tiger and there are no miniskirt-wearing trophy wives waiting for them back at the cave.

In China, many of the sons see hardly anything of either parent during the early years, often sent thousands of miles away to live with their grandmas. Yet their rates of mental illness and crime are many times lower than those in America.

Michael Diamond, an American psychoanalyst, has recently made the case for fathers as conduits to the wider world for small children. Perhaps he is right, but the scientific evidence that the second parent needs a willy is still absent. If my two-year-old son benefits from my presence, I suspect it's the extra pair of hands that is crucial, not what is between my legs Oliver James is the author of Affluenza: How to be successful and stay sane. The updated 2nd edition of They F*** You Up: How to survive family life has just been published

References

Norman Dennis, Families Without Fatherhood, Civitas: Institute for the Study of Civil Society.

Golombok, S et al, 1996, Journal of Child Psychology Psychiatry, 38, No 7, 783-792.

Study of 411 boys: Juby, H et al, 2001, British Journal of Criminology, 31, 22-40.

Michael Diamond, My Father Before Me, London: Norton.

Subscribe to get access to the content on this page.

If you are already a Tes/ Tes Scotland subscriber please log in with your username or email address to get full access to our back issues, CPD library and membership plus page.

Not a subscriber? Find out more about our subscription offers.
Subscribe now
Existing subscriber?
Enter subscription number

Comments

The guide by your side – ensuring you are always up to date with the latest in education.

Get Tes magazine online and delivered to your door. Stay up to date with the latest research, teacher innovation and insight, plus classroom tips and techniques with a Tes magazine subscription.
With a Tes magazine subscription you get exclusive access to our CPD library. Including our New Teachers’ special for NQTS, Ed Tech, How to Get a Job, Trip Planner, Ed Biz Special and all Tes back issues.

Subscribe now