SNP hostages to fortune
With an eye to next May's election the strategy, clearly laid out in Alex Salmond's conference speech last week, could be productive. But the party is aiming for government, at least as leader of a coalition administration. That is where the resemblance to "old" Labour looks uncomfortable. If the SNP is going to make promises to public-sector groups to win their votes - exactly the disastrous strategy adopted by Michael Foot in 1983 - there is little sign of the smack of firm government needed from Scotland's first administration. Voters, too, may be chary of supporting a party appealing to the self-interest of focus groups.
The SNP's education policy has come a distance since the days of more Lallans in the classroom and restored student grants. As in its conference organisation, there is greater cohesion and more professionalism. The hand of financial spokesmen is evident in the disappearance of hopeless promises about student largesse. But listening too closely to teacher unions might become a siren call for voters and certainly would create hostages to fortune for a government.