'Sport and setting are alive and well'

20th November 2009 at 00:00

I went to school as a student in the 1970s, during what might have been regarded as the decade of comprehensive liberalism. Yet setting and competitive sport seemed very much alive.

When I arrived as headteacher at Islington Green in 2002, the school was still basking in its reputation for singing the chorus "We don't need no education" for Pink Floyd. I thought I would discover a liberal school committed to equal opportunities and non-competitive sport.

Then the PE department presented their plans for sports day, which could only be described as pre-runner for London's 2012 Olympic bid. I tried to trim down their plans, worried about cost and that only a minority of children would feel "included and successful". I was presented with an ultimatum from the PE department, then my deputies, and finally a petition - not from the athletic elite but from some of the most troubled and challenged learners in the school. This group suddenly found their voices to tell me that I was suppressing their human rights.

One lad called Stanley said: "Why have you banned sports day, Sir? I wanted to see Kenny run like the wind, close up, even if I can't manage it myself." The sports day went ahead.

I shouldn't have been so surprised. Many of the assumptions I'd had about the teaching profession from reading the press were shattered when I finished my PGCE in Leeds. When I took up my first teaching job at a school in a leafy middle-class area of Essex I had been expecting to see more mixed-ability teaching. Instead I was struck by the rigidity of the setting. The maths department went as far as to line up every child - literally - according to their IQ and put them in class groups accordingly.

Even though the headteacher was very keen to introduce mixed-ability teaching, he only went as far as allowing faculties to do it, rather than imposing it. The debate in the staff meeting was impressive.

"Speaking as a born-again Christian," said Nigel, the careers teacher, "mixed ability is anathema to my beliefs." That was calling on the highest support possible, I reflected.

"Speaking as a born-again Marxist atheist," I replied, "I cannot accept God's part in this debate." I was forever known in the staffroom afterwards as a Marxist and an atheist.

English departments traditionally favour mixed ability, and maths setting. Arriving as head of Islington Green, I had expected a powerful mixed- ability lobby. Instead I discovered a school that had always set by ability. Following a visit to charter schools in New York, I tried to introduce an integrated curriculum in to key stage 3. It involved all- ability teaching. The staff voted against it at an NUT meeting. We rowed back the plan for a year to get people ready for its introduction.

So competitive sport is, in my view, alive and well. And setting is a friend to the majority of teachers and schools, as far as I can see. Contrary to the media reports, the more inner-city you go, the more embedded it becomes. Never in my 28 years of teaching (five local authorities, seven schools, 14 years of headship) have either ever been banned.


The guide by your side – ensuring you are always up to date with the latest in education.

Get Tes magazine online and delivered to your door. Stay up to date with the latest research, teacher innovation and insight, plus classroom tips and techniques with a Tes magazine subscription.
With a Tes magazine subscription you get exclusive access to our CPD library. Including our New Teachers’ special for NQTS, Ed Tech, How to Get a Job, Trip Planner, Ed Biz Special and all Tes back issues.

Subscribe now