What to spare, what to share and where to begin with 911
Ten years after 911, Americans are taking stock. How does that day look now through the lens of time? How have we changed? How should we remember?
For America's teachers, a decade has done little to resolve another set of perplexing questions: how do we tackle those dreadful events in the classroom? How do we convey the significance without terrifying the children, often too young to remember? How much detail to spare them, how much to reveal?
This year, teachers in New Jersey have an advantage. The state is recommending its public schools follow a new curriculum, developed to help teachers resolve those difficult dilemmas.
MaryEllen Salamone instigated the programme, which was developed by Families of September 11 with the New Jersey Commission on Holocaust Education and Liberty Science Center. Ms Salamone's husband, John, died on the 104th floor of the World Trade Center. A mother of three, she grappled with how to tell her own children about that day. By the first anniversary, she realised teachers were floundering. "Some were doing nothing, some were scaring the bejeezus out of the kids," she says.
And then she took her children to visit Northern Ireland. In the Parliament Buildings in Belfast they saw a memorial to victims of The Troubles. "One of my sons said, `Look Mom, Osama Bin Laden has been here, too.' It was clear to me that terrorism was really misunderstood in America."
The curriculum takes a broad view of the history and causes of terrorism, with 911 as a case study along with other examples from history - Omagh, the Munich Olympics massacre and the Oklahoma bombing. Unfortunately the US press has insisted upon referring to it as the 911 Curriculum; the correct title is in fact Global Security, Terrorism and 911 in the Classroom.
September 11 falls right at the start of the autumn term, before teachers have got to know their new students and learnt whether any lost family members. As a result, teachers have tended to talk about the attacks around the anniversary and not return to them. By contrast, this curriculum peppers the subject throughout the school year and across disciplines.
Trauma specialist Donna Gaffney helped target the lesson plans to each age group. They start with simple narratives of courage and heroism, becoming progressively more analytical further up the school.