Less is more when drawing up rules of behaviour

27th November 2015 at 00:00
A code of conduct can easily buckle under the weight of its own complexity. It’s time to choose a simple life

Exceptional learner conduct is underpinned by intelligent policy. But what are the key elements of successful conduct and behaviour systems? And what small changes can you make today to build consistency for staff and learners?

Short and sweet

Start with something simple. Ask a range of different learners what they think the rules of the college are. Ask some staff too. They will doubtless look into the distance and mutter, “Oh, yes, I did see some once.” Or they’ll laugh heartily as if you are being deliberately facetious.

They don’t know them. Nobody knows them. Because the list is so ridiculously long.

More often than not, there will be a code of conduct that extends to 20 or 30 rules, with separate procedures hidden deep in college policy around everything from guns, knives and drugs to badgers and atomic weapons.

There are rules about dress, and rules about conduct in the canteen, in the corridor and on visits and work placements. The inmates of Alcatraz had 52 rules (and a long time to learn them). How many does your college have?

The chaos of too many rules means that leadership teams have designed inconsistency into their policy at the very foundations. If learners and staff can’t remember the rules, you have too many. If they have to look them up online, search for a poster or refer to a weighty induction file, you have too many.

Why would anyone need more than three simple rules? Whether they are “Ready, respectful, safe”, or “Dignity, humility, integrity”, the titles are not important. What is critical is that staff refer to them constantly in positive and negative behaviour interventions. They should be woven through college life: the naming of awards at the end of the year; the language of each faculty; the daily recognition that great colleges always give their learners.

Remove barriers

Alongside the “conduct policy” there is always a separate “disciplinary policy”, which is operated by senior leaders whose specialism is managing bureaucracy – not managing learners.

Rigid disciplinary systems with “levels”, “written warnings” and “formal meetings” fuel a detachment on the part of learners that does not meet anyone’s needs. At its worst, it is an unempathetic travelator out of college rather than an attempt to genuinely re-engage.

When learners are struggling, give them support, not just red lines and stern faces. They don’t need the dark suits of doom but a learning coach, detached from any process, to support, mentor and guide. A problem-solver, not a process monkey. A skilled, empathetic specialist who can work with the learner to meet their needs and stem the flow of poor conduct. Someone who understands that learners with additional needs are not “behaviour problems”.

Cause for concern?

At the heart of bad policy lies the “cause for concern” system, a relic of the old school that simply refuses to die. When staff pass a slip to a more senior colleague, the learner understands one simple message: “You can’t deal with me.”

Nothing says “I give up” more than “cause for concern” slips. In many colleges, the system is overloaded with minor referrals. Senior staff don’t have time to deal with the most urgent cases, communication breaks down and messages go unanswered. Mistrust between staff and senior leaders begins to breed.

Get rid of the “cause for concern” system. Throw it away. Without bits of paper or emails to defer responsibility, people start working together, communicating more clearly and managing poor behaviour in teams, at source.

The best colleges have policies that are simple, concise and fully understood by everyone. They don’t create a Kafkaesque process that no one truly understands. They use simple policy to drive consistent practice and get on with the real business of teaching, learning and inspiring.

Paul Dix is a behaviour specialist and founder of Pivotal Education. He tweets at @pivotalpaul

Log-in as an existing print or digital subscriber

Forgotten your subscriber ID?


To access this content and the full TES archive, subscribe now.

View subscriber offers


Get TES online and delivered to your door – for less than the price of a coffee

Save 33% off the cover price with this great subscription offer. Every copy delivered to your door by first-class post, plus full access to TES online and the TES app for just £1.90 per week.
Subscribers also enjoy a range of fantastic offers and benefits worth over £270:

  • Discounts off TES Institute courses
  • Access over 200,000 articles in the TES online archive
  • Free Tastecard membership worth £79.99
  • Discounts with Zipcar, Buyagift.com, Virgin Wines and other partners
Order your low-cost subscription today