Why Catchphrase could hold the secret to formative assessment

Dan Williams, an FE practitioner in the Midlands, reflects on whether posing questions to the whole class is the best way of evaluating learners

News article image

In the early 1990s, my Saturday evenings generally consisted of shouting catchphrases at the television to the beloved Roy Walker. My favourite part of Catchphrase, the show he presented, was the bonus round where contestants would, after guessing a saying correctly, press their button to remove one of nine squares that were covering a cartoon depicting another catchphrase.

Unless they were extremely lucky, the contestants needed to remove the majority of the squares in order to get enough information to guess the phrase correctly. This is akin to using formative assessment in the classroom – no, stay with me…

I’ve been fortunate enough to observe a lot of lessons, and one thing seems to be the weapon of choice for many teachers in their use of formative assessment to elicit evidence of learning. In my opinion, this weapon is relatively ineffective, yet so many draw comfort from using it. What is this weapon? It is the question that is thrown out to the group with little thought from the teacher. For learners, it is a case of survival of the fittest, with only the quickest and most confident answering. It is here that we have a problem.

Ask a question in this way and you will check the understanding of one, maybe even two individuals in the class. That’s comparable to revealing a single square from the Catchphrase board; you will have gleaned very little information to help you solve the puzzle. If you move on with the delivery of the class at this particular point, there may be learners in the class who still have misconceptions, and this could impact on their future learning.

As Paul Black and Dylan Wiliam put it in their 1998 paper: “Teachers need to know about their pupils’ progress and difficulties with learning so that they can adapt their work to meet their needs.” Therefore, without conducting a broad assessment of learner understanding, we are at risk of not gathering enough evidence of learning, and thus not being able to meet learner needs.

So what methods might we use to conduct a broader assessment and create a bigger picture of learner understanding?

Pose, pause, pounce, pass

This questioning strategy sees the teacher pose a question to the whole group. They then pause for about 10 seconds, allowing all learners to formulate a response, before pouncing on someone to respond. Of course, this only gleans information from one learner, so without giving the correct answer away, the teacher must then pass to another learner to give their response and so on. This method can prove far more effective than the rather problematic questioning approach described earlier. However, it can also be quite time-consuming and should be used with care.

Think, pair, share

This involves learners being given a key question or problem based on their learning. They are asked to think about the problem individually for a while, before discussing their thoughts with a partner. In this way, they can hone their response together to share with the rest of the group. The problem here is that we don’t know who contributed what to the answer within each pair. But once again, if we are trying to build a bigger picture, this goes some way towards doing that.

Hinge-point questioning

For this, you should prepare a number of multiple-choice questions that are pertinent to the topic, then use them at a transitional point in the session between activities. Learners must answer questions simultaneously, either on mini-whiteboards or by holding up a certain number of fingers that match the answer. This approach does give a broad assessment of learner understanding, but you need to plan questions with care so that the learner is only able to reach the correct answer by using the relevant thought process for that task.

This is an edited version of an article from the 15 January edition of TES. Read the full coverage in this week's TES magazine, available in all good newsagents. Subscribers can read the article here. To download the digital edition, Android users can click here and iOS users can click here

Want to keep up with the latest education news and opinion? Follow TES FE News on Twitter and like TES FE News on Facebook



Log in or register for FREE to continue reading.

It only takes a moment and you'll get access to more news, plus courses, jobs and teaching resources tailored to you