# One reason A-level results were lower than expected

Calculated A-level grades may have seemed lower than expected, but this was because of an artificial boost in prior attainment, say experts

Prior to the government U-turn over A-level grading, some schools and colleges were left scratching their heads over calculated grades that seemed far lower than what they would have predicted for their students.

In a new blog for FFT Education Datalab, statistician Dave Thomson explains one reason why this was the case.

GCSEs 2020: 3 things to expect in this year's results

A-levels and GCSEs U-turn: The end of the algorithm?

Schools were expecting somewhat higher results for their 2020 A-level cohorts because the GCSE average point score of the group had increased. The group seemed to have higher prior attainment, and would therefore achieve higher grades in their A levels, the theory went.

However, the measurement by which prior attainment was calculated relied on an average GCSE point score. As Mr Thomson writes, the "average point score is simply the average grade in reformed GCSEs".

"So if you took 10 GCSEs and you received grade 8 in five of them and grade 7 in the other five then your average would be 7.5," he adds.

However, the A-level cohort in 2019 took fewer reformed GCSEs, because 2017 was the first year that reformed GCSEs in English and maths were introduced.

The Department for Education has devised a conversion scale for the old A*-G grades to be mapped onto the new 9-1 scale, with an A* grade equating to 8.5, and a B to a 5.5, for example.

However, Mr Thomson notes that "because the method of equating A*-G grades to 9-1 grades used by the Department for Education is not directly equivalent, it appears that the 2020 cohort has slightly higher prior attainment overall than the 2019 cohort".

At the upper end of the GCSE grade distribution, GCSE average point scores were around a fifth of a grade higher.

While he writes that this "doesn't sound like much", it had consequences for how schools calculated A-level grades based on prior attainment.

Using a hypothetical scenario where a group of 20 A-level maths candidates had an average GCSE point score of 8.1 in 2020, the Department for Education's transition matrices would have predicted that 48.4 per cent of the group would gain an A*.

However, "GCSE average point scores were around 0.2 points higher in 2018," Mr Thomson notes.

If the GCSE average point score for the group is lowered by 0.2 percentage points, just 21.6 per cent of the cohort would gain an A*.

"To get around this problem, Ofqual age-standardised the GCSE average point score of each cohort when making adjustments based on prior attainment," he writes.

"However, no details have been published on the age standardisation process to the best of our knowledge," he adds.

For schools using the DfE's matrices to make their own calculations of expected grades, this explains why calculated grades may have been lower than expected: prior attainment looked like it had increased, but only because the cohort in 2020 took more reformed 9-1 GCSE subjects.

It only takes a moment and you'll get access to more news, plus courses, jobs and teaching resources tailored to you

## Latest stories

### Scottish election 2021: SNP manifesto for education

Ahead of the 6 May election, the SNP pledges to reform exams and give teachers more power
Henry Hepburn 15 Apr 2021

### College covid tests: Drop in tests and positive results

With many colleges in the middle of the Easter break, the seven days beginning 1 April saw 135,591 lateral flow tests conducted in colleges and 16-19 schools in England
Tes Reporter 15 Apr 2021

### Magazine podcast: Tutoring, role models, DofE memories

Join us for our weekly discussion about some of the hottest topics included in the latest issue of Tes magazine
Tes Reporter 15 Apr 2021

### Today's school, education and teacher news: LIVE 15/4

The hub for specialist education news for those working in schools and everyone who is interested in them
Tes Reporter 15 Apr 2021

### Call for inquiry into teacher Covid infections

'Proper investment' needed from government to make schools 'safe', says medical expert
Amy Gibbons 15 Apr 2021

### 4 key questions to ask if considering a new job abroad

Covid shouldn't put you off a dream move overseas - but there are important things to consider, says this international teacher
Karolina Malinowska 15 Apr 2021

### Why are we so reluctant to let go of exams?

High-stakes assessment is harming students – we need to learn from what the rest of the world is doing, says Bill Lucas
Bill Lucas 15 Apr 2021

### Today's school, education and teacher news: LIVE 14/4

The hub for specialist education news for those working in schools and everyone who is interested in them
Tes Reporter 14 Apr 2021

### Put £10m behaviour pot into mental health, say teachers

Teachers’ leader backs call to spend £10m DfE behaviour hub programme fund on mental health counsellors instead
Dave Speck 14 Apr 2021

### GCSEs 2021: Should schools be running full mock exams?

Some schools are running full mock exams to gather recent evidence to support A level and GCSE grading decisions – but is this fair?
Catherine Lough 14 Apr 2021