'Apprenticeships benefit the "already-haves"'

An employer-led system disproportionately favours staff who already hold qualifications, writes Kathleen Henehan

Kathleen Henehan

Unemployed and disadvantaged people need supporting into apprenticeships

This morning the Department for Education (DfE) published figures outlining the number and type of apprenticeships that were started during the first month of 2019. January isn’t a big month for apprenticeship starts. However, it does mark the completion of the first half of the academic year and, as such, is a good time to take stock of how today’s system compares against the recent past.

So first, the numbers. Provisional figures tell us that 29,100 people began an apprenticeship during January 2019 and 226,000 began one between August 2018 and January 2019 (the first half of the 2018-19 academic year).

Read more: Apprenticeships starts continue to rise

Background: Government launches £2.5m apprenticeship campaign

Opinion: Drop in younger apprentices 'could be a major problem'

A continuing pattern

Figure 1 shows that the total number of starts (so far) this academic year is 17 per cent down on the same period in 2016-17 (final figures, and before the levy was in operation) and just 4 per cent up on the same time last year (after the levy was in place). In other words, the initial post-levy fall in starts has stabilised; we are now operating in a system that offers fewer apprenticeships than in the past.

apprenticeship statistics 1
Figure 1: Number of apprenticeship starts by age and level, England

Of course, much of the narrative around the apprenticeships system has shifted away from the headline numbers and towards its composition of starts. Even ministers appear to be playing down the likelihood of hitting that 3 million starts by 2020 target. And it’s in the composition of courses where we see substantial change. As the chart below shows, the number of level 2 apprenticeship starts has broadly halved between the first half of 2016-17 and the first half of 2018-19. In contrast, the number of level 4 starts has more than doubled (albeit from a lower base). 

apprenticeship statistics 2
Figure 2: Percentage change in starts by age and level, Aug-Jan 2016-17 to Aug-Jan 2018-19, England


On the one hand, we shouldn’t worry much about the declining number of level 2 apprentices over the age of 25. After all, last year we at Resolution Foundation reported on apprenticeship evaluation figures that showed more than half (55 per cent) of people on these courses were unaware that they were even an apprentice.

Moreover, the 2016 apprentice pay survey found that almost one-in-three apprentices aged 25 and over in their second year were paid less than the legal minimum. In a world where we want to raise the profile and stature of vocational education, these kind of courses risk causing major damage to the apprenticeship brand.

Skills gap

On the other hand, recent Resolution Foundation research has found that workers with lower-level qualifications, and/or who work in lower-skilled occupations receive less frequent training than their counterparts who either have higher-level qualifications or work in higher-skilled occupations. This is a skills gap that needs filling (as figure 3 below shows) – and level 2-3 apprenticeships could have an important role to play in this.

apprenticeship statistics 3
Figure 3: Proportion of 22-64 year olds in receipt of work-related training over the previous three months by two-digit occupation and the average level of attainment within each occupation, 2016-18, UK. Bubble sizes reflect each occupation’s share of employment during 2016-18. 


The implication of our analysis is that those who leave the formal education system behind the curve are offered fewer opportunities to either progress into a better role, or to perform their own role more competently.  

We know that this is a problem for firms, who often complain about workers’ competencies. In 2017 they stated that 4.4 per cent of UK staff lack the skills to be fully proficient in their job, with these "skill gaps" tending to be concentrated in lower-skilled roles. Yet despite their complaints, firms are exacerbating this problem by offering less frequent training to employees in roles that are said to suffer from an above-average level of skill gaps.

apprenticeship statistics 4
Figure 4: Proportion of 22-64 year olds in receipt of training over the past three months, by highest qualification held and skill gap density, 2016-18, UK


Poor quality apprenticeships

So, while we can welcome the drop off in poor quality apprenticeships, we’re also right to worry that today’s apprenticeships system risks reinforcing a longstanding pattern in which training and development is (disproportionately) directed towards the "already-haves". We shouldn’t be surprised by this either.

After all, the apprenticeships system is "employer-led" and the apprenticeship levy, by its very nature, is paid by large employers – many of whom are likely to be staffed by already-highly-qualified workers. A quick glance at figure 5 helps to illustrate levy payers’ (relatively stronger) tendency to focus on apprenticeships at higher levels.

apprenticeship statistics 5
Figure 5: Composition of starts by employer's levy-paying status, England


Over the coming months, the Resolution Foundation will be digging further into the mechanics of this. We’ll be looking at how the composition of starts differs by levy-payer status and industry, and what this means for the number and type of opportunities for future learners.

Kathleen Henehan is research and policy analyst at the Resolution Foundation. The graphs are based on Resolution Foundation analysis of Department for Education and ONS data

Register to continue reading for free

It only takes a moment and you'll get access to more news, plus courses, jobs and teaching resources tailored to you

Kathleen Henehan

Find me on Twitter @kathleenhenehan

Latest stories

Geoff Barton

Omicron, nativities and the DfE: Another fine mess

Schools are being told what to do by those with no concept of the reality of running a school - and it's only making an already tough situation a lot harder, explains Geoff Barton
Geoff Barton 3 Dec 2021
New headteachers - here are 9 things you need to know

Headteacher wellbeing and sources of 'streth'

Former headteacher Chris McDermott set out to find out the true causes of leader stress and support – and in doing so coined a whole new term, as he explains here
Chris McDermott 2 Dec 2021
Transdisciplinary learning: how to embed it in your school

Why you need a transdisciplinary curriculum

At the Aspirations Academies, six hours a week are dedicated to applied transdisciplinary learning - but how does it work? And should you apply something similar at your school?
Steve Kenning 2 Dec 2021