The Behaviour Question

Tom Bennett

I'm on placement at a challenging school and am teaching three classes, two of which are known to be disruptive. But it's the 'nice' class, a high-ability Year 9 group, that seems to have turned on me. One girl has complained to other staff that I'm 'picking on her' and that the rest of the class agree (apparently). They swan in smirking at me, in a way that seems prearranged, and one of the boys tries to take apart every comment I make.

What you said


It sounds like they have noticed you are a bit nervous and are trying to push it. Children this age can certainly be unpleasant to teachers - they often seem to get a kick out of making you feel uncomfortable. If they try to intimidate or upset you by picking up on little things you say and twisting them, I would defuse it by looking directly at them, pausing and waiting. They will almost always quail. If they don't, explain what you meant in a literal way and be slightly patronising. Smile slightly.


They aren't picking on you in a personal way, nor bullying you. They are just being grotty Year 9s. It is totally normal and not anything like a personal attack. Year 9s get nothing from school - not the academic pressures of Years 10 and 11, nor the "fun" of Years 7 and 8. They will always be a handful if they can.

The expert view

Unfortunately this is a common situation for new teachers. They start off with a class that resents change and the introduction of a new authority. Automatic deference to rank is dead, so the pupils expect you to "prove yourself" over time.

Alas, this means that many children will take the arrival of a new teacher as an opportunity to do as they please. They know, or believe, that you won't be there for long, are a little uncertain and might not know the ropes so well. And many will exploit that.

The sad thing is that many nice kids will do this, too, especially if they are triggered by strong personalities in the room. Because they don't see you as an authority, attempts to modify their behaviour by issuing instructions or consequences can lead to confrontation. This often ends up as a simple "No" followed by "They're picking on me". It is an extension of the "It wasn't me" excuse. It is not meant to be the truth; it is a deflection to avoid trouble and work.

The key thing you need with these pupils is persistence. The relationship takes time and it is built on trust. They need to know that you know what you want. You need to be consistent, have clear ground rules and establish consequences for bad behaviour. If someone repeatedly disrupts your lesson, have them removed to the exclusion room.

Reboot your relationship with the class. Tell them you want to remind them what works in a lesson and what doesn't. Tell them what will happen if they cross the line. Then make sure it happens, the same day if possible. If they fail to attend detentions, escalate your response and get others involved.

Some teachers can get sniffy when a new colleague asks for help, but to hell with them and their professional amnesia about how hard it is to begin. You have a class to teach.

Tom Bennett is author of The Behaviour Guru and Not Quite a Teacher.

Post your questions at

Register to continue reading for free

It only takes a moment and you'll get access to more news, plus courses, jobs and teaching resources tailored to you

Tom Bennett

Latest stories

GCSES: Do grades really predict earnings?

GCSEs: Do grades really predict earnings?

As research is published around the impact GCSE grades have on future earnings, principal Ian Pryce calls for insight into whether vocational grades behave in a similar way
Ian Pryce 25 Jul 2021