Ofsted quashes Jewish school's 'inadequate' rating

Inspectorate admits it was wrong to find that the King David High School, in Manchester, had segregated girls and boys unlawfully

John Roberts

Ofsted has quashed an inspection report finding that the King David High School in Manchester was inadequate.

Ofsted has quashed an inspection report that rated a Jewish school as inadequate after admitting it was wrong to conclude that the school had unlawfully segregated pupils.

The inspectorate has withdrawn the report into the King David High School, in Manchester, which had been taking legal action against the inspectorate.

The school is now rated as "outstanding", dating back to its previous inspection in 2015.


Background: School considers legal threat over inadequate report 

Quick readJewish state school considers single sex academies

Ofsted: Inspectorate in segregation court case


The school operates in three sections, with one for boys (Yavneh Boys) and another for girls (Yavneh Girls), and a third section that is not segregated.

Ofsted had said in an inspection report, published in June, that the way the school kept some boys and girls separate in different sections of the school was “unlawful segregation on the grounds of faith and belief and sex".

However, the inspectorate has now said this judgement was wrong.

A spokesperson said: “We have taken the very unusual step of giving consent to the quashing of the most recent inspection report on King David’s High School in Manchester, which was published in June 2019.

“We have agreed with the school that, given the school’s particular arrangements, it was not open to us to conclude that there was unlawful direct discrimination on grounds of either sex or religion and belief, when comparing a pupil in either of the single-sex streams with a pupil in the mainstream. 

“Quashing the report will allow us to re-inspect the school at an appropriate time, looking again at how it manages the separation of pupils by sex and assessing the education it provides against our new inspection framework.”        

King David High School has said previously that 30 per cent of its school is part of a Yavneh structure in which boys and girls are kept separate.

The Ofsted report, which has now been withdrawn, had said that the different treatment of pupils constituted "direct discrimination contrary to the Equality Act 2010 and breaches the school’s public sector equality duty".

However, in a letter to parents at the time, the school’s chair of governors Joshua Rowe said: “The school lawyers and counsel believe that Ofsted is wrong on the law.” 

Commenting on the removal of the Ofsted report, Michael Brotherton, a partner in the Stone King law firm  which  represented the school, said: “Stone King was pleased to represent the King David High School in this matter; we were instructed on the basis of our strong reputation in the education sector and are delighted with the outcome that the school has achieved.” 

Register to continue reading for free

It only takes a moment and you'll get access to more news, plus courses, jobs and teaching resources tailored to you

John Roberts

John Roberts

John Roberts is North of England reporter for Tes

Find me on Twitter @JohnGRoberts

Latest stories

EAL: How teachers can support new pupils who have English as an additional language

5 steps to help a new EAL learner

Integrating non-native speakers into the classroom is an important job for any teacher – one literacy lead offers advice
Laura May Rowlands 28 Oct 2020