Pupils have expressed deep concerns about the election of Donald Trump as US president, teachers have said, but schools across Scotland have vowed to use the election as a learning opportunity.
Teachers and parents told TESS that, in the wake of the US election result last week, pupils of all ages were coming into school worried about Mr Trump’s handling of nuclear weapons or what he will do to minority groups.
Schools, however, have been rising to the challenge and helping pupils to understand the political situation across the Atlantic.
“There’s never been a better or more important time for education, particularly citizenship education,” said Mark Priestley, a professor of education at the University of Stirling, as he spoke at a conference last week.
Anne Hutchison, Scotland’s teacher of the year in 2015, said children as young as seven had been expressing concern about Mr Trump’s victory.
“You must not shy away from discussing it - children are genuinely concerned about it and therefore it has to be discussed,” said Ms Hutchison, who works at Glasgow’s Carmyle Primary School. She has handled concerns about Mr Trump’s finger being on the nuclear button by discussing - with pupils aged 8 and 11 - how the US government is constructed and highlighting the role of advisors, which “makes it difficult to make unwise decisions”.
‘Fuel for discussion’
Ms Hutchison said it was also crucial to explore with pupils why Hillary Clinton lost the US election, looking at, for example: the fact that many Americans mistrust the current administration; whether the two-party political system is outdated; and the influence of money and the media on presidential races.
Amid widespread despondency around the world in the wake of the result, Ms Hutchison saw a silver lining for teachers. “It must be used as a wonderful learning opportunity to look at the political system in another country - children are the future of our world and must know what is happening around them,” she said.
Earlier this year, TESS reported on research showing that some immigrant pupils in the US were “terrified” of Mr Trump and thought he would send them back to their countries of birth (“My students think Trump will put them into slavery”, 22 July).
Teachers in Scotland have reported similar levels of dismay since last week’s result. Susannah Jeffries, a primary teacher in Fife, said that before the election Mr Trump was largely viewed by pupils as “a total joke” but she was now “aware of lots of kids in a range of schools being deeply concerned”.
The result has made Ms Jeffries determined to show pupils the importance of making good choices in both day-to-day life and on national and international levels.
‘There’s never been a better or more important time for education, particularly citizenship education’
Dave Keenan, principal teacher of modern studies at St. John’s RC High School in Dundee, said there was lots of discussion about Mr Trump after he was elected, with pupils of all ages and abilities “fascinated” by him. He added that the president-elect’s views on race and gender could provide much fuel for debate.
Lessons for the school’s S3 pupils, who were already studying US politics and society, were tailored to follow events as they unfolded, often using online news sources. Meanwhile, Higher modern studies and politics pupils have been studying influences on voting behaviour in the UK as part of their courses.
Shortly after the US result, teachers were already comparing Mr Trump’s victory with the Brexit vote and the rise of Ukip, and drawing parallels between disillusionment with the political establishments on either side of the Atlantic.
Fife modern studies teacher Sarah Tennant said many pupils were shocked that the US had elected a man who “openly insulted minorities, women and races other than whites”.
But, added Ms Tennant, there were valuable lessons to be learned from the situation: that “we need to respect the democratic systems” and “keep an open mind” about the consequences.
Robert Macmillan, a principal teacher of social studies in Fife, said that the uniquely Scottish subject of modern studies, which covers contemporary political and social issues, would help young people to come to a measured view of Mr Trump’s victory.
“Modern studies teachers are used to teaching controversial issues with sensitivity,” he said. “As long as folks avoid their own feelings dominating any discussion, they should be able to point out the sharp differences in views [that] US citizens have over Trump, his victory and potential policies.”