# GCSE counting calories question defended by exam board

Critic says her sister had to leave the Edexcel GCSE maths exam because she was recovering from an eating disorder

An exam board has defended a GCSE maths question that involved working out the number of calories in a breakfast, after coming in for criticism on social media.

One complaint said a pupil had been forced to leave the Edexcel GCSE maths exam last week after seeing the question, while another criticised the board for posing a question about calorie counting to “the age group most likely to suffer” from eating disorders.

Pearson – the company behind Edexcel – defended the question as “valid”, but urged students to get in touch if they believed it had impacted their performance.

Quick read: 'What exactly was the point of exam reforms?'

Quick listen: How to judge teacher and school performance

Want to know more? How to help girls overcome exam anxiety

The question appeared in Edexcel’s calculator paper, which was sat by candidates on Thursday 6 June.

It read: There are 84 calories in 100g of banana. There are 87 calories in 100g of yogurt.

Priti has 60g of banana and 150g of yogurt for breakfast.

Work out the total number of calories in this breakfast.

One critic said her sister had been forced to leave the exam before of the question: "A girl called ‘pretty’ was counting her calories after eating a banana and the kids had to work out how much she had eaten…my sister is a recovering anorexic who had to leave the exam due to this".

Another user commented: “One of the questions in my maths exam triggered me LIKE IT WAS ABOUT CALORIES AND I JUST WANTED TO CRY BC HOW LOW IVE BEEN FEELING ABOUT MY BODY.”

A third user criticised the board for the question:

Another pupil said that the question had been “triggering” for her and that the calories were "not enough to eat for a breakfast”.

In a tweet published this afternoon, Pearson said: “In a maths exam taken last week, candidates were asked to solve a practical problem calculating the number of calories in a banana and a yoghurt.

“We have reviewed the question and find it to be valid. We encourage any student who thinks that this question may have impacted their performance to get in contact with us via the school.

“We understand the summer exam series is a stressful time for students and we wish all students every success with their remaining exams.”

It only takes a moment and you'll get access to more news, plus courses, jobs and teaching resources tailored to you

## Latest stories

### Schools should publish their exclusions data, say MPs

New report calls on schools to present data on pupil exclusions and the numbers who leave them each year
Catherine Lough 26 Jul 2021

### MPs: DfE's lack of homeschooling data is 'astonishing'

Commons Select Education Committee calls on government to create a new register of homeschooled children
Catherine Lough 26 Jul 2021

### GCSEs: Covid rules for exams to relax from autumn term

No need for 2m distance from staff in exams from September, new Department for Education guidance says
Catherine Lough 26 Jul 2021

### How to make your teaching truly research-informed

Reading one piece of literature is never enough to build a teaching and learning policy on, writes Sam Jones
Sam Jones 26 Jul 2021

### Why should school students learn about philanthropy?

There is huge value in learning about the importance of helping and caring for others, says Matthew Crammond
Matthew Crammond 26 Jul 2021

### FE hero: 'Without the funding, FE cannot survive'

Meet this week's Tes FE hero: Kerri Fitzpatrick, English lecturer at Leicester College
Tes Reporter 26 Jul 2021

### Exams 2022: How to stop an examiner crisis next year

Will there be a dearth of GCSE and A-level examiners next year after two years of no marking? It's a situation we can't allow to happen, says this senior examiner
Chris Eyre 26 Jul 2021

### Vaccine passports for FE students 'premature', says AoC

Simple practicalities for students make vaccine passports in further education tricky, says Association of Colleges chief executive David Hughes
Kate Parker 26 Jul 2021

### Parental engagement: 5 lessons from primary schools

Primary schools are great at parental engagement - so what can those in other educational settings learn from them? A leader offers some advice
Dan Locke-Wheaton 26 Jul 2021

### 6 ways to help primary pupils learn self-regulation

The new early years framework will require the teaching of self-regulation. Here one international educator offers advice on how to make this work in the classroom
Jess Gosling 26 Jul 2021