What do pupils want from a teacher?
She was a relentless bundle of energy with a big, infectious smile and a booming voice,” said BBC presenter and journalist Naga Munchetty of her favourite teacher, Ms Berry.
For multiple-gold-winning Olympic cyclist Sir Chris Hoy, it was Mr French from primary school who stood out, mainly because of his humour and his ability to make everyone feel like they were part of a team: “It wasn’t really ‘us’ and ‘him’ - we were all in it together.”
The traits valued by these famous faces, sharing their memories of their best teachers in the pages of Tes, echo the qualities that primary and secondary children today believe are important for teachers.
Research involving hundreds of Scottish children - described by those behind it as “the most up-to-date and detailed data on the qualities and values of a good teacher” - reveals that pupils want teachers who are approachable, encouraging, friendly, caring and knowledgeable, and who take account of the individual needs of those in their class. However, what pupils in Scotland prize above everything else in a teacher is kindness.
When the responses from the nearly 600 five- to 18-year-olds who took part in the research by the charity Children in Scotland were fed into Wordle - the tool that generates word clouds from text and gives greatest prominence to the words appearing most frequently - “kind” was found to be the word mentioned the most.
But what does that mean in reality? According to 2015 research cited in a previous Tes article, kindness is “any behaviour that is intended to benefit others, such as sharing, helping and comforting” (“Caped crusader’s mission to promote kindness in schools”, 6 September 2019). It might sound straightforward, but the impact, the academics involved said, goes beyond making someone feel good or cared for. Indeed, they highlighted that these so-called “prosocial behaviours” have likely played a fundamental role in the development of stable societies and, consequently, the success of our species.
Schools are frequently described as microcosms of society, so the pupils involved in the Children in Scotland research perhaps reflect a deeper collective urge to emphasise the importance of being kind. Certainly, the findings echo a 2018 YouGov survey of 586 children aged 6-15, in which 27 per cent of respondents said that the trait they looked for most in a great teacher was “a kind nature”. This made it more prized than any other trait - the next most valued quality was “good listening skills”.
And schools seem to be starting to appreciate the positive impact that an explicit focus on kindness can have. Earlier this year, Glasgow City Council handed out 2,000 “kindness” books to primary headteachers so that pupils could record a moment of kindness with a friend. The book is then passed to the friend, who records their own good deed, and so on. Council education director Maureen McKenna said she hoped the books would help Glasgow towards its goal of becoming a “nurturing city”.
Meanwhile, a message from children at Dunnottar School in Stonehaven, Aberdeenshire resonated around the world when their Christmas video urging people to “choose kindness” - inspired by hit movie The Greatest Showman - went viral, even catching the attention of the film’s star Hugh Jackman.
The Children in Scotland research was carried out last year, commissioned by the General Teaching Council for Scotland, which is in the process of “refreshing” teachers’ professional standards and is consulting teachers on this.
Researchers also found that the pupils’ visions of what makes a good teacher did not always reflect their actual experiences of school, where they had sometimes seen an absence of kindness. The pupils they spoke to and received input from had “some experiences of stressful classroom situations” and, therefore, a key message to emerge for teachers was “be positive and do not shout”.
The researchers - through a mix of direct work with pupils, an online survey and work fed in from schools in four council areas - found that the children typically believed that “a good teacher does not shout”. Children find shouting “scary” and say it affects their ability to learn, and that teachers’ voices should be raised only if someone is in danger.
“Shouting or angry behaviour was felt to undermine relationships between teachers and pupils, and to be counterproductive in terms of supporting learning and motivation,” the researchers write. “While teachers are clearly under pressure, our findings show that they should shout only as a last resort, perhaps to deal with safety issues, not behavioural or work-based ones.”
Pupils’ belief that learning is undermined by the stress of being on the receiving end of shouting is backed by previous research, the Children in Scotland team says, which “has identified stress and fear [as having] a negative impact on capacity to learn both in immediate and longer term”.
Suzanne Zeedyk, a Scotland-based psychologist and a campaigner on adverse childhood experiences (ACEs), recently told Tes Scotland that, if she had her way, not only would behaviour charts be scrapped in schools, but also shouting would be banned and cuddling commonplace (“The ‘teddy bear schools’ transforming behaviour management”, 23 August 2019).
Responding to the new research, she says that kindness may sound “light and sweet” but it is a children’s rights issue - children have a right to be treated with respect.
She would like to see the focus in schools shift so that “wellbeing comes first”, as opposed to literacy and numeracy, which, she argues, have become the standard by which schools are measured under the push by the Scottish government to close the poverty-related attainment gap.
“Our focus is on the Attainment Challenge and people experience that as a focus on literacy and numeracy,” Zeedyk says. “If that becomes the standard by which you are measured, it is entirely understandable that a focus on wellbeing, emotions and kindness would get lost.
“But if you feel safe and calm and heard, and noticed, and you get that sense of belonging you need, then your biology relaxes and you feel safe. Then you are in a good place to learn things that are academic.”
Teachers who shout do so sometimes because they are feeling overwhelmed, but also because they think it’s acceptable, believes Zeedyk. “We need cultures that say it is not OK to shout at children and [in which] you don’t have the right to do that, and we need to help teachers to self-regulate.”
She adds that people do not shout if they are “not stressed to the max”, but that “we ask teachers to do things that drain them - we push their self-regulatory system to the max”.
“It takes courage for teachers and schools to hear what the report says: to hear that the students they work hard for feel uncomfortable and unhappy is hard,” says Zeedyk. “The risk is [teachers and schools] feel offended and go into denial. They need to stay brave enough to be curious and think of the experiences in school that can help.”
The children’s comments were sought so that they could be reflected in the official values of the profession as they are updated. Ultimately, the GTCS - which presented the findings to coincide with its annual professional learning awards in September - discovered that the children’s views chimed with the existing national values for teaching, which focus on integrity, trust and respect, and social justice.
“Although we used different language and words from the children, when you map them together they are absolutely in line,” says Charlaine Simpson, senior education officer at the GTCS, who is leading the refresh of the values for teaching.
However, the research looked not just at the values and characteristics of the perfect teacher, but also at how a teacher who embodies these values might behave in the classroom. “This research was about the values of teachers, but it wasn’t just about the theory - we wanted to hear from children and young people what that looked and felt like. How would a teacher put that into practice?” says Elaine Kerridge, co-author of the research and Children in Scotland’s participation and engagement manager.
So a nurturing and supportive teacher, the children suggest, will say “hello”, ask pupils how they are, tell jokes and smile, and if they are tired or sad will give them a cuddle.
There has been some debate about whether the relatively new trend of greeting every child individually as they enter the class is time well spent or time wasted. Chris Keates, acting general secretary of the NASUWT teaching union, attacked the “meet and greet at the classroom door” when addressing the union’s Scotland annual conference in Glasgow in May.
But the children who took part in the research were enthusiastic about such greetings, says Kerridge, and Zeedyk cites the practice as “a kindness” that schools can introduce to make their students feel noticed, given that, at other times, the education system does not feel very personal.
Kerridge, a former teacher, believes that some of the children’s comments reflect the success that schools have had in promoting “rights-respecting” approaches through programmes such as Unicef’s Rights Respecting Schools Awards. Pupils want boundaries but they also want “a flatter, more equal relationship” with their teachers, she says.
The pupils may object to shouting, but they do want rules and consequences. However, they also want to be involved in coming up with the rules and for teachers to stick to them and apply them fairly. And they want to be asked for their feedback on lessons and for the teacher to be open to comments from pupils about what they might learn about.
“Children are now calling for a more equal relationship with their teachers,” says Kerridge. “They don’t want teachers to dictate to them - they want a say in the rules and the success of lessons. They want their own skills to be recognised by the teacher and for the teacher to be open to suggestions from them about what they might learn about. They want to be able to choose if they work alone or in groups.”
What the report highlights, she says, is that children want to have “positive relationships with other humans”, which covers basic kindness from teachers but also recognition that pupils deserve more influence in school than in the past.
“They just want these people who they see six hours a day, every day, to be a nice, sound person,” Kerridge says. She acknowledges, however, that achieving this is harder than it sounds and that there are “a lot of different aspects” to it.
For Simpson, who is also a former teacher, the research really shows “the complexity of a classroom”. The focus from the outside is often on attainment and results, but that is not what the children home in on. They want to progress and to have knowledgeable teachers - but they also want to be cared for and supported, she says. “If you look at the things they said, they were not about attainment. They were more about the child having a positive experience and being educated holistically,” Simpson adds.
At times, you do wonder if it is realistic to think that every teacher can be possessed of such skill and awareness to offer all the above. But then one child in the survey talks about it being “like magic” when a teacher gets it right; the way that they “always have the right words”. Kindness is a word that children often use to define a crucial quality in teachers, but empathy may be another: the ability and willingness to see a situation from a pupil’s perspective, and to react accordingly.
And the researchers believe that kindness is more than a way of making pupils feel momentarily warm and fuzzy - it just might transform their whole experience of school.
Emma Seith is a reporter for Tes Scotland. She tweets @Emma_Seith
To have your say on the “refresh” of professional standards for teachers in Scotland, go to gtcs.org.uk/consultations by 20 December
This article originally appeared in the 22 November 2019 issue under the headline “What makes the perfect teacher? (according to your pupils)”
You need a Tes subscription to read this article
Subscribe now to read this article and get other subscriber-only content:
- Unlimited access to all Tes magazine content
- Exclusive subscriber-only stories
- Award-winning email newsletters
- Unlimited access to all Tes magazine content
- Exclusive subscriber-only stories
- Award-winning email newsletters
You need a subscription to read this article
Subscribe now to read this article and get other subscriber-only content, including:
- Unlimited access to all Tes magazine content
- Exclusive subscriber-only stories
- Award-winning email newsletters
- Unlimited access to all Tes magazine content
- Exclusive subscriber-only stories
- Award-winning email newsletters