Explain science behind school reopening plans, SNP told

‘Every bit’ of scientific evidence must be available to Scottish teachers to give them confidence about returning to the frontline, says Labour
14th July 2020, 6:30am

Share

Explain science behind school reopening plans, SNP told

https://www.tes.com/magazine/archive/explain-science-behind-school-reopening-plans-snp-told
‘explain Science Behind School Reopening Plans’

School staff and parents deserve to be told the scientific evidence for classes returning next month, Scottish Labour has said.

Schools are due to reopen in August, with no requirement for physical distancing between children.

Education secretary John Swinney has been urged to reveal what the evidence is and allow schools to examine it themselves.


Background: John Swinney’s statement on schools reopening: what we learned

Coronavirus: Advisers support scrapping of 2m distancing for pupils

News: Council reveals plan for staggered schools reopening

Opinion: ‘Pupils coughed in my class on purpose’


Scottish Labour education spokesman Iain Gray said the scientific reasoning must be explained to give staff and pupils the confidence to return.

Under the Scottish government’s proposals, pupils are due to go back to schools from 11 August if coronavirus is adequately suppressed, with a blended model of both in-school and at-home learning as a contingency plan.

Mr Swinney said there would be a review on 30 July, 12 days before children are due to go back to school, which will be the last chance to make the decision on a full return.

Urging him to release the evidence, Mr Gray said: “We’re now just one month away from the return of full-time face-to-face education and the Cabinet Secretary is still skirting around the scientific safety information that should put education staff and parents at ease.

“It’s not enough to give a brief description of scientists’ position - we need to know how and why they reached that position.

“Schools and councils had been planning for Mr Swinney’s blended learning model and phased returns, only to have the plans changed at the last minute without even being consulted.”

He added: “Nobody wants to keep children out of classrooms for any longer than is necessary but after a global pandemic and worldwide lockdown it is understandable that school staff, pupils and their families should have every bit of information available to them so that they know they are not being put at risk.

“The time is up. The Scottish government must present the scientific safety evidence or lose the confidence of the staff they’re ordering to the front line.”

School staff have yet to be told if there will be social distancing between adults when schools return and whilst masks are mandatory in shops and on public transport in Scotland the Scottish government has yet to say definitively if they will be worn in primary or secondary schools.

It has been pointed out that this could lead to a situation where pupils wear a mask coming into school on the bus, but take it off when they arrive.

Speaking to Tes Scotland for a podcast about the reopening of schools earlier this month, Mr Swinney said that it was “likely” that school staff would have to follow “physical distancing requirements” when schools returned after the summer, even though the plan was for no social distancing among pupils. He added that, for most pupils, he believed, there was “no tangible case for wearing face masks in school”.

Mr Swinney said, however, that wearing a mask might be appropriate for some senior students who were “essentially young adults”, and that there were “questions about staff”. He added that the government was waiting for guidance from its scientific advisers on the issue.

Want to keep reading for free?

Register with Tes and you can read two free articles every month plus you'll have access to our range of award-winning newsletters.

Keep reading for just £1 per month

You've reached your limit of free articles this month. Subscribe for £1 per month for three months and get:

  • Unlimited access to all Tes magazine content
  • Exclusive subscriber-only stories
  • Award-winning email newsletters
Recent
Most read
Most shared