‘Train teachers to constructively challenge authority’

Scottish education is ‘coasting’ and it is time for ‘greatly increased’ school autonomy, says think tank

Emma Seith

‘Train teachers to constructively challenge authority’

A Scottish think tank has outlined its priorities for education, saying the system is “coasting” and the opportunities pupils are given are of “good quality but not world leading”.

Today, the Commission on School Reform – which includes education academics and is part of the Reform Scotland think tank – published its manifesto for education.

The commission argues that Scottish education has become “dangerously over-centralised” and that “a culture of compliance has developed”, which is “inhibiting innovation”.


Background: 'Pupils need individualised support – not more school'

Magic wand: What one thing would you change about Scottish schools?

Education recovery: University scheme provides tutors for over 300 senior pupils

News: Teachers have second-lowest autonomy of 11 professions

Magazine: Should Scotland keep exams post-Covid?


It is calling for “greatly increased school autonomy”, with “critical decisions” taken by headteachers, staff and other stakeholders, which are “not subject to external reversal”.

The commission also wants to see the creation of “an extensive programme of teacher professional development”, which promotes “leadership and independent thinking” and which makes it explicit that teachers have a responsibility “to offer constructive challenge to authority”.

The commission says Education Scotland should be abolished and an independent inspectorate established, “overseen by a board independent of government influence and answerable to Parliament”.

When it comes to exams, the commission says frustration with the Scottish Qualifications Authority’s (SQA) handling of assessment during the coronavirus pandemic has prompted some critics to suggest that formal examinations should be abolished entirely and replaced by assessments of coursework.

It says it believes “this would be profoundly mistaken”, adding: “The objectivity of examinations and their freedom from plagiarism and outside help are of great value. A blend of different kinds of assessment has great merit.”

However, it says the Scottish qualifications system should be reviewed during the next Parliament and, in the shorter term, the validity of exams should be improved by “reducing reliance on simple recall”.

It also says it should be clarified that schools can bypass the SQA and are “entitled to secure examination and certification services from the supplier of their choice”.

An Education Manifesto for 2021 and Beyond also includes the following recommendations:

Keir Bloomer, the chair of the Commission on School Reform, who was involved in the early design of Curriculum for Excellence, said: “Scottish school education is coasting. It lacks creativity, and it lacks the capacity for innovation.

“We should not disparage our schooling for poor quality but nor should we deceive ourselves into believing that it is world leading. It is not.

“If we want to be proud of our schooling system, and to be able to credibly claim it to be world leading, we need seismic change. What the commission proposes in this manifesto can be the start of a renaissance in Scotland’s schooling.

“However, it is up to politicians to make this happen. Our future is in their hands.”

Register to continue reading for free

It only takes a moment and you'll get access to more news, plus courses, jobs and teaching resources tailored to you

Emma Seith

Emma Seith

Emma Seith is a reporter for Tes Scotland

Find me on Twitter @Emma_Seith

Latest stories

Careers guidance: How schools can make the most of careers education

How to get careers education right

Covid has made careers education more important than ever, says Oli de Botton – and here's how to do it well
Oli De Botton 6 May 2021