Looking back over my 30 years of research in education, one thing stands out to me: I could not have done it without classroom observations.
The research programmes I have conducted have looked at class-size differences, within-class groupings, the experience of pupils with SEND, and the deployment and impact of teaching assistants – and they all used naturalistic systematic observations. Despite this, my sense from reading journals and attending conferences is that the tradition of observation research in classrooms (quantitative and qualitative) has declined over time.
This is unfortunate, as the observation components in our research have shown again and again the central importance of classroom processes.
For example, in our research on teaching assistants (TAs), we found a consistent negative association between the amount of TA support and pupil academic progress, even when controlling statistically for other factors likely to confound the association. Some in education dismissed these findings as being wrong or suggested the relationship was not causal. Others saw them as a chance to save money and reduce the TA workforce.
Through classroom observations, however, we were able to explain further the connection between TA support and pupil attainment. Observations revealed that pupils in most need tend to be given primary support by TAs, at the expense of support from teachers.
Furthermore, TA support is more likely to close talk down and provide answers to pupils, while teachers tend to open up talk and provide the basis for thinking. It is therefore not so much TA support but the type of support that is provided that makes a difference. Our conclusion was that it is not TAs who are the problem, but the way they are used in classrooms.
Throughout this project and others, close observations of classrooms also revealed something else: the classroom is an ecosystem.
The classroom ecosystem
Rather than there being a linear cause-effect relationship between variables, as is implied by many traditional approaches to research in psychology and education, I’d argue that we need an alternative approach - one that more closely matches how things work in everyday contexts, is more holistic and recognises the interconnectedness of variables. Without this, we risk misunderstanding the nature of things if we artificially change aspects of the whole in the hope of determining what is causing what.
I was recently awarded a Major Research Fellowship (MRF) by the Leverhulme Trust to develop a new approach to making sense of what goes on in classrooms that captures essential aspects of this ecosystem. The aim was to integrate research findings, identify and then apply what seemed to be the key dimensions and features, and arrive at an overarching framework. The result was what I call the “eco-relational approach”, which is described in my new book, Inside Classrooms: How Contexts and Relationships Shape Learning and Teaching.
It has three dimensions that characterise classroom proximal processes:
- The immediate classroom context, including layout, the organisation of students into groups, the types of tasks, and interactional contexts.
- Interactions and relationships between teachers and pupils, and also between pupils.
- The way contextual and relational elements are aligned or not in the complex interconnected and dynamic nature of the classroom system.
I give the example of group work as one application of the eco-relational approach. Our classroom observations showed that although pupils - especially at primary level - are frequently seated in small groups, this is often more in the interests of classroom management than as a strategic approach to learning.
The quality of pupil contributions to group work was often not high, with some pupils dominating, some disengaged, and some disparaging others' efforts. Group work does not happen naturally; to be successful, teachers and pupils need preparation.
In the book, I use the eco-relational idea to show how this preparation involves, firstly, organising the classroom context and learning activities that facilitate group working – through attention to group size, composition, task type, and interaction norms – and, secondly, developing pupils’ relational and communication skills and teachers’ skills in supporting groups undertaking group work.
This was the approach used in our SPRinG project, which is described in the Inside Classrooms book. We found it led to higher academic attainment and higher-level contributions to group work.
Peer collaboration is, then, a rich resource to be developed, but we should treat collaboration as teachable, not something that will happen automatically. Teachers should explicitly teach pupils how to collaborate, reason together, and regulate group processes. In the case of teaching assistants, we need to use them to strengthen, not replace, teaching, ensuring all students retain access to the teacher, peers and curriculum.
The overall principle is that teaching is not simply about enacting instructional techniques; it is about considering alignment of elements in the classroom ecology. Rather than searching for the best method or intervention, it is better to seek coherence between, for example, class size, TA support, space, grouping, task complexity and interaction demands.
Impact on learning increases when the system parts work together.
Peter Blatchford is emeritus professor in psychology and education at UCL Institute of Education, and the author of Inside Classrooms: How Contexts and Relationships Shape Learning and Teaching