High-stakes exams 'best way of assessing kids', says Cambridge International boss
High-stakes exams are here to stay, says Rod Smith, group managing director of international education at Cambridge University Press & Assessment.
Of course, as head of one of the biggest assessment companies in the world, Smith would say that, but he says the reality is that the rise of AI means a trusted system for exams is vital.
“High-stakes assessments are going to be here for a long time to come,” he says. “Fundamentally, [they] are the best way of assessing what kids know and can do.”
Many will agree, with calls for exam reforms post-pandemic being undermined by AI-related fears that other forms of assessment – such as essays, reports and investigations – are less reliable.
Exam marking changes
In January, for instance, Ofqual chief Sir Ian Bauckham told the Commons Education Select Committee that the coursework element of qualifications such as A-level English and history was vulnerable to AI malpractice.
This doesn’t mean Smith is against AI overall; he says that it could, in the future, be “transformative, not just in terms of what we currently do, but potentially in how we capture what young people know and can do more effectively”.
For Cambridge, adapting to this latest challenge is par for the course: it has been delivering exams internationally since 1864, with IGCSEs – its most popular qualification in terms of entries – first examined in 1988.
Today, learners in 156 countries sit Cambridge International exams, requiring an administrative feat Smith calls “a logistical miracle”.
It runs three exam series in total, with the biggest taking place over May and June, after which millions of papers must be marked in a 12-week window.
Next year, that turnaround time will be reduced when it comes to AS- and A-level results, which the body recently promised to publish almost a fortnight earlier than usual, on 28 July 2027.
Cambridge International is exploring how AI might help speed up the marking process, and has been experimenting with AI-assisted marking for its digital mock service.
Adapting to global challenges
However, AI isn’t the reason results day is being moved forward. Its role in marking is still in the testing phase, and Smith says the change to results day is simply about doing what they usually do, but faster, to help give students “more time to sort out their next steps”.
He admits it is a big challenge – “We’ve not done this lightly” – but believes they have put in "all the work to make sure we’ll do it right”.
Another change Cambridge is looking at is streamlining its marking processes by scanning scripts closer to where candidates sit exams, rather than flying all the scripts back to the UK.
“Sending stuff backwards and forwards around the world is not the best way for the future, and we’re doing a lot of work [towards] moving that forward.”
Of course, it was a different kind of evidence that flowed into the exam body from the Middle East this year after the exams were cancelled because of the Iran War – a situation Smith admits was not straightforward.
It was “an unbelievably stressful period” for students and teachers working in schools in the Middle East, says Smith, noting also that gathering and marking the portfolio of evidence that replaced the exams for 80,000 entries in four countries was “a very large-scale process” that “involved an awful lot of extra work”.
He adds: “We are very proud of the fact that we delivered results for those kids in those four countries on the same day as the students in the rest of the world. And we are very proud of the fact that, for a great many learners, that enabled them to make their next steps.”
Nevertheless, some school leaders in the Middle East spoke to Tes about their frustration with exam boards in the wake of results day, criticising demands on schools in terms of the evidence requirements, and maintaining that subsequent grades for entire cohorts made “no sense”.
Smith’s response is that a portfolio of evidence is “a different kind of assessment from an exam, and therefore it will perform differently”.
He continues: “The great majority of our schools and learners are very supportive of what we did, and what we need to do to continue to be a trusted partner.”
Nevertheless, Smith agrees that exam providers – and, of course, schools – could more often find themselves facing circumstances in which exams are unable to run.
After all, when exams were cancelled in 2020 because of the pandemic, it was described as an “unprecedented” moment. Six years later, it happened again.
Now, with increasing geopolitical tensions and disruption caused by extreme weather, there’s a fear among school leaders and teachers that the cancellation of exams could occur more regularly.
Smith acknowledges that “the world is not getting any simpler”, and that no exam series goes by without “some form of challenge”. When we speak, for example, the body’s November exam series is underway, and he notes that there are floods in Italy and haze in Southeast Asia.
The rise of digital exams
Given such challenges, the group is doing more every year to see “what the alternatives are” should contingencies be needed, Smith says. This could include portfolios of evidence, and “calculated assessments” that use completed assessments to work out a missing grade.
Cambridge is also looking to increase its offering of modular qualifications, which provide a more “staged” approach to assessment, he continues.
For example, as of the 2027-28 school year, there will be a new modular option for AS- and A-level mathematics in which students are assessed regularly, as opposed to just at the end of the course.
Cambridge has suggested that similar modular options could also be introduced for sciences, although Smith stresses that the approach will only be taken “where it’s appropriate for the subject”. It is thought, for instance, that modular assessment wouldn’t be as suitable when it comes to languages.
The digitisation of exams could also help if exam disruption becomes more commonplace, Smith suggests; the body has set itself a target of 85 per cent of its high-stakes qualifications having a digital option by 2033.
However, while digitisation solves certain problems, it “opens up others”, Smith points out. The recent issues with the PHP programming language, which led to the shutdown of websites around the world, made that clear.
Then there is the additional challenge, when you operate in over 160 countries, of schools and nations being at very different stages in terms of infrastructure and readiness.
When Cambridge ran its first high-stakes digital exams in 10 countries, during the June series this year, it had to prepare for everything from electrical outages in South Africa to the huge cohorts of students sitting exams in some US schools, explained Jesse Dvorchak, director of digital exams, when she spoke to Tes in July.
Growing up in education
And that variety of contexts continues to expand. In 2025, the body surpassed the 1,000-school milestone of settings following its curriculum in South Asia, the Middle East and North Africa.
Meanwhile, between 2022 and 2026, the total number of AS- and A-level entries grew by 45 per cent – going from 647,353 to 939,420 – and IGCSE entries by 26 per cent, from 894,926 to more than a million.
“It’s been a story of growth over the last five years,” says Smith, who became group managing director in August 2022, having worked for Cambridge University Press since 2015.
In total, Smith – whose background is in marketing – has worked in education for 30 years, in publishing, qualifications (both international and vocational) and edtech. And he was “very rooted in education” long before that.
That is because his mother – the youngest of six daughters and the first in her family to go to university – became a teacher and went on to run and own a school in north London that Smith attended and “grew up in”.
As well as being “absolutely my hero in life”, Smith says, his mother and her story also reflect what it is that has kept him working in the sector.
“I wanted to be involved in education because it is the ultimate way in which equity is enacted in society.”
Looking at AI and why exams at 16 matter
And he is keen to point out that Cambridge is, of course, not just about exams.
“Cambridge is the curriculum that many schools are running from the age of three to 19,” he says.
“Exams are an important part of it as an indicator of what kids know, but we do a huge amount to support that curriculum, too. Our mantra – our mission – is about how we help young people be ready for the world.”
When it comes to national systems, the pace of change is often slow, he says, but Cambridge is able to be more responsive.
“I’m not criticising any individual systems, but we can continually refine and improve our curriculum.”
This is why one of the next areas it is looking at is AI, and there are plans to publish “a very significant piece of work on what AI in education looks like” before Christmas.
“I don’t think we can say we’re helping young people if we’re not helping them be ready for a world where AI is going to be pretty ubiquitous,” adds Smith.
Nevertheless, he acknowledges, it is challenging to design a curriculum “that works in 160 countries where there may be very different attitudes to certain things or different societal norms”.
The approach Cambridge takes is to “create a curriculum around the fundamentals children need to know and the skills they need to have”, but with “flexibility” built in to bring “local flavour” to what is being taught.
Many seem to agree: more than 7,000 schools in 147 countries deliver IGCSEs and, this year, entries increased by three per cent on 2025.
What, then, does he make of stories like the one involving a school in Singapore that ditched GCSEs in part because of the belief exams at 16 are something of a British peculiarity?
It is “absolute nonsense”, he says. “When we analysed this, we found that, in the top 19 education systems in the world, 16 of them have some form of external assessment at age 16.”
Doing exams at 16 often makes sense, he argues, because it’s “a natural break in the system”, when students tend to move from a broader curriculum to one that is more specialised.
Exam results at that stage give “very powerful metrics for those children to make the right kind of decisions about where they go next,” he says.
Universities also like IGCSEs and have “confidence” in them as a reliable indicator of student performance, he adds.
Smith knows, however, that the group cannot assume things will continue as they have in the past, and must “continually evolve in a world that’s changing”.
Recent moves to introduce a new argumentative essay and replace many long-established texts on its syllabus demonstrate this willingness to make substantive changes.
Meanwhile, Smith reveals that the group plans to publish a paper on the future of assessment in March, and that the role of AI is almost certain to be mentioned in it; just don’t expect a prediction of the traditional exam's demise.
“An exam – for now and, I think, a long time to come – is still the most reliable way in which a student’s knowledge and their understanding and their skills can be evaluated,” Smith says.
To get essential briefings from Tes magazine delivered directly to your inbox, sign up to our newsletters. And stay up to date with the latest education news via the Tes magazine mobile app – available on iOS and on Android
Register with Tes and you can read five free articles every month, plus you'll have access to our range of award-winning newsletters.
Keep reading for just £4.90 per month
You've reached your limit of free articles this month. Subscribe for £4.90 per month for three months and get:
- Unlimited access to all Tes magazine content
- Exclusive subscriber-only stories
- Award-winning email newsletters
You've reached your limit of free articles this month. Subscribe for £4.90 per month for three months and get:
- Unlimited access to all Tes magazine content
- Exclusive subscriber-only stories
- Award-winning email newsletters
topics in this article